Noisy carp on the bottom

cokomo

.
Feb 15, 2008
22
Hunter 28.5 wichita
We are on an inland lake in the midwest and now that summer is here we spend many nights on the boat. The carp have become a problem beating on the boats bottom all night. Does anyone know a way (other than hand grenades over the side) of making them stop.

Sleepless sailboater.
 
  • Like
Likes: SycloneDriver
Jun 2, 2004
160
Beneteau 393 Lake Texoma, Texas
Maybe shine a light into the water to scare them away or attract them to something besides your boat?
For those who don’t sail in fresh water and have not had the pleasure of having carp impact your sleep, just try to imagine (with no exaggeration) someone banging (not tapping) on your hull with a hammer. On my lake, carp travel in large schools and they tend to 7-10 pounds. Carp are sucker feeders and are attracted to the slime that accumulates on the hull. While fresh water boats do not incur the type of growth found in salt water, even a recently painted or scrubbed hull will develop a thin layer of slime. That is feast food for carp. Carp are extremely fond of protected marinas and less active in more open waters. As the water gets warmer, the carp get more active. Bright lights do seem to run them off, but unless you can install very bright lights that penetrate feet below the surface and around the clock, that solution only works whey they start hammering on the hull and drive you topside with your bright flashlight or spotlight. Also, keep in mind that in a marina, the noise traveling thru the water from neighboring boats is just as bad as if they are attacking your boat.

I recently observed our state fish and wildlife folks driving through our 1,000 boat marina with a nice electronic shocking system that stuns carp and they scoop them up. Unfortunately, not a system an available or legal for the rest of us. Can be fun to bow fish, but then again, you only hunt after they wake you up.

if any of you have found the magic bullet to solve this problem,, would love to hear about it.
 

degas

.
Aug 14, 2023
56
Tanzer 29 Lake Ontario
Huh. That might explain this: One night at a slip in eastern Lake Ontario something thudded on the hull hard enough to noticeably knudge the boat. There were no wind or waves. My only guess at the time was that it was a large (-for-Canada) turtle.

At that marina at night there are often splashes on the surface or even a gentle thump on the hull but this one made me go out to shine a light in the water.
 
  • Like
Likes: Timm R Oday25
Nov 22, 2011
1,296
Ericson 26-2 San Pedro, CA
For those who don’t sail in fresh water and have not had the pleasure of having carp impact your sleep, just try to imagine (with no exaggeration) someone banging (not tapping) on your hull with a hammer. On my lake, carp travel in large schools and they tend to 7-10 pounds. Carp are sucker feeders and are attracted to the slime that accumulates on the hull. While fresh water boats do not incur the type of growth found in salt water, even a recently painted or scrubbed hull will develop a thin layer of slime. That is feast food for carp. Carp are extremely fond of protected marinas and less active in more open waters. As the water gets warmer, the carp get more active. Bright lights do seem to run them off, but unless you can install very bright lights that penetrate feet below the surface and around the clock, that solution only works whey they start hammering on the hull and drive you topside with your bright flashlight or spotlight. Also, keep in mind that in a marina, the noise traveling thru the water from neighboring boats is just as bad as if they are attacking your boat.

I recently observed our state fish and wildlife folks driving through our 1,000 boat marina with a nice electronic shocking system that stuns carp and they scoop them up. Unfortunately, not a system an available or legal for the rest of us. Can be fun to bow fish, but then again, you only hunt after they wake you up.

if any of you have found the magic bullet to solve this problem,, would love to hear about it.
So dynamite it is.
 
Nov 8, 2007
1,613
Hunter 27_75-84 Sandusky Harbor Marina, Ohio
It is definitely breeding activity. The breeding season will pass, and the carp will turn to normal. I forget how long it lasts,
 
Jun 2, 2004
160
Beneteau 393 Lake Texoma, Texas
Oh sure ,like the carp need music and lights to get even more romantic ????
Unless they mate 4-5 months, afraid the mating thing is an urban myth. Hate to the spoilsport, but they are just feasting on the slime/growth on the bottoms of our boats.
 
Jan 1, 2006
7,984
Slickcraft 26 Sailfish
I was in a Chinese restaurant years ago in China Town Manhattan and next to our table a family had an enormous Carp cooked, sitting on its belly in the middle of the table. They were going at it like Piranhas. It was revolting to me. But I don’t eat fin fish anyway.
 
Jun 9, 2008
1,850
- -- -Bayfield
I've experienced same and just fell asleep anyway. I do not recommend a hand grenade as you might find yourself sitting on the bottom with carp eating for face.