The Hunter 23.5 is fitted with a Z-190 mast; however, there are two mast steps with each having a mast foot that are different. Each mast step has a different bolt pattern. The original mast step was larger while the newer one has a smaller bolt pattern. My concern is the embedded aluminum plate in the deck of the 23.5 will it accommodate both bolt patterns. I did inqurie with Hunter owners prior to the Hurricane but it will be some time before they respond to my request for information.
You can when reordering a mast for the 23.5, take measurements of the four bolt hole pattern holding the mast step to the deck requesting the appropiate mast step.
However, you can improvise should the mast step is not damaged, order a 1/2 inch aluminum plate the size of the old mast step with the larger holes predrilled from a machine shop near you.. Then take the smaller mast step and drill and tap for the new mast step to be attached to the aluminum plate