New engine for O'Day 25, recommendations requested

Status
Not open for further replies.
T

Tor

My Evinrude 6HP (20'' shaft) lower end has seen it's day. I just went and looked at a 2001 Evinrude 9.9HP 4-Stroke that was a steal at $1,000, but am concerned it is to large. I have a hydrolic lift motor bracket on the transom rated to 15HP. I was told it should be fine for the engine as its rating is sufficient. My concern is it seems so bulky. California passed a new law this year to not sell 2 stroke engines this year. I have found two 2001 model 2 stroke Nissans. A 5HP single cylinder 20'' shaft for $1,100 or a Nissan 9.8 twin cylinder 25'' shaft for $1800. I have always heard great things about Nissan. I also located a '94 Yachtwin 8HP 25'' shaft for $515 on the Internet. Another option I have is to drive to Nevada and get a 2002 2 stroke, but I am trying to respect the principle of the law. What do you have for an outboard? What are your thoughts on the three choices I have listed? How fast and efficient is your outboard and it's HP? Does anyone have a 9.9HP 4 stroke on a 25? Would you lean toward new or used? After 15 years with my last engine the $1,000 to $1,800 price points seem high. Then again struggling to get home with limited power, or worse, floating without an engine after the used one bites the dust at the worst possible time would create big regrets for saving a buck. TIA, Tor
 
D

Dick Lemming

Get a 4 stroke.

Tor, I just bought a Nissan 5hp longshaft 4 stroke from Woody's Marine, 2001 model new in the box, for $1025. It's for my O'Day 26. I wanted a 6hp, but couldn't find one at the right price. Check with Jon Sherlock (O'Day 26 directory) though, as he found a source for a new Nissan 6hp for around $1175. They weigh about 65-70 lbs and should work fine on your 25. If a 5hp will do, contact Woody at woodysmarine.com.
 
T

Tor

Why a 4 stroke?

Dick, Thanks for your quick response. Why do you recommend a 4-stroke? I have heard they have more torque on the low end. I also am considering the ecological aspects. I called Woody's today and have to call back tommorow about a 6HP 2-stroke he has. Does the 5HP give you enough power? I am drawn to the 9.8HP Nissan and am still wrestling the price issue. They are available for $1500 if they are shipped out of state. Tor
 
J

Jonathan Sherlock

Looking for a motor too

As Dick said, he and I have been talking about motors lately too. We both have 26s. I am replacing a Johnson 9.9 2 stroke. I am also in CA and have decided to order a Nissan 6 hp 4 stroke. I will be ordering it from www.outboardsales.com. It is $1159 plus about $40 shipping. And like Dick said I think it weighs about 57 lbs. I am in a lake and I am certain that this will be more than enough power for me. I see you are in Sausilto, so I am sure youu know better than I do about what kinds of conditions you'll encounter in the Bay. Although if you've been using a 6 hp currently in the Bay then I am sure I will be fine in my little lake.
 
D

dave

up to 15 is ok

i have a 9.9 mariner and it is fine boat is okay with a 15 but only really necessary if you sail ihn the ocean or alarge unprotecyed area. 2 or 4 stroke are fine and all are good makes so go with your personal chpoice of weight,looks/costs good luck
 
Status
Not open for further replies.