My mistake

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dec 2, 1999
15,184
Hunter Vision-36 Rio Vista, CA.
The 1-2-B switch is fine until you "forget" to reposition the switch to the house bank (depending on your wiring setup).

The Blue Sea setup seems to be the best setup in my opinion. Let the electronic determine what needs to be charged and reserve your "reserve battery".
 
Feb 26, 2004
23,086
Catalina 34 224 Maple Bay, BC, Canada
Ah

Steve, that's only if you have your alternator output going to the switch. If it's run to the house bank, many of us conclude that you put the switch on your house bank position, after running your alternator output wire directly to the house bank. Only reason to switch the 1-2-B switch to reserve is if you need to - never use both. Simple. We put our switch on "House" and just leave it there.
 
Last edited:

Bob S

.
Sep 27, 2007
1,805
Beneteau 393 New Bedford, MA
Stu,

Maybe you should finish that paper! I may not have a good understanding of electricity but reading your descriptions have been the most logical (to me). I think it's done similarly in Nigel Caldor's book.

This is my understanding;

1 Alternator output goes directly to house bank to charge.

2 Emergency or Reserve bank uses a combiner or echo charger for it's charge.

3 The 1, 2 ,both switch is used for output only and in most cases the house bank does everything including starting the motor. The reserve bank,(#2 in my case), will only be be needed if my house is totally dead which should never happen if you have a battery monitor.

If the alternator doesn't go thru the switch it doesn't make a difference in what position it's in because both banks will always be charging when the engine is on and there is no chance of frying the diode.

But if the switch is in both position then your house bank is really both banks.
This would be bad!:naughty: Your switch should never see both.

Is that correct in it's simplest form, layman's terms. This always seems to be a confusing subject.

Now the hard part....trace the existing wiring....fun.
 
Feb 6, 1998
11,711
Canadian Sailcraft 36T Casco Bay, ME
Stu,

Maybe you should finish that paper! I may not have a good understanding of electricity but reading your descriptions have been the most logical (to me). I think it's done similarly in Nigel Caldor's book.

This is my understanding;

1 Alternator output goes directly to house bank to charge.

2 Emergency or Reserve bank uses a combiner or echo charger for it's charge.

3 The 1, 2 ,both switch is used for output only and in most cases the house bank does everything including starting the motor. The reserve bank,(#2 in my case), will only be be needed if my house is totally dead which should never happen if you have a battery monitor.

If the alternator doesn't go thru the switch it doesn't make a difference in what position it's in because both banks will always be charging when the engine is on and there is no chance of frying the diode.

But if the switch is in both position then your house bank is really both banks.
This would be bad!:naughty: Your switch should never see both.

Is that correct in it's simplest form, layman's terms. This always seems to be a confusing subject.

Now the hard part....trace the existing wiring....fun.

Wow this entire thread summarized into one short concise post! You nailed it!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.