My friends are alive, boat in on bottom of S. Pacific

Aug 31, 2007
296
Catalina 30 Petoskey, Mich.
I got the worst and best email this morning, my friends from Sault Ste. Marie Canada survived the most horrible thing on the way to the Marquases, as far from land as possible. They have sailed from Canada, Great Lakes, Erie Canal, AICW to Panama, through the canal on their way across.

Here is Randys log.



End events of S/Y NIRVANA NOW
04/23/2015


End Events of S/Y NIRVANA NOW
On the 8th of April Nirvana Now sank to the bottom of the South Pacific Ocean at latitude 07 54' S, longitude 119 11' W in a section of ocean farther from land than anywhere else on earth due to damages from the heavy seas we had experienced for over a week.
After contacting the S/Y CONTINUUM through the Seafarer's ham radio network Bob and Mona sailed hard to weather for almost two days to our rescue as we floated disabled. Due to their efforts and skill we were able to transfer safely to S/Y CONTINUUM be carried to The French Marquesas as the boat that brought us so much joy for the eighteen years we owned her settled beneath the waves.
We are now in Tahiti and expect to be in Canada by the end of May.
The details
6 th April
I noticed that sea growth on bottom of the boat was slowing us down. We removed the barnacles at the water line.
Three coats of Mission Bay bottom paint were applied as to the manufacturer's directions in November 2015 while at Shelter Bay Marina in Colon Panama.
Afternoon of 6 th: I noticed that the forestay was loose. It is attached to the bow of the boat and the top of the mast to support the mast. Inspection showed that the deck where the forestay attaches had started to part from the hull. We attributed this to the state of the sea over the last three days which had been a 2-3 meter swell at a period of 3-5 seconds.
We rolled in the jib sail mounted on the forestay to reduce strain on the stay and kept the main sail up with three reefs. We helped support the forestay with a spinnaker halyard and a spare jib halyard attached to the port and starboard forward mooring cleats.
We steered a course of 265 degrees which was a downwind course, and our rhumb line course to our destination Nuku Hiva, to reduce the strain on the forestay.
We noticed water accumulating in the bilge requiring to be pumped out several times.
0300 UTC: I checked into the Seafarer's Net on 14.300 Mhz and explained the situation as critical. I arranged with their assistance to have the S/Y CONTINUUM to change course and meet us to lend assistance if required.
0350 UTC: I called in on 14.300 Mhz and talked to W3ZU Fred to ensure that we were doing all we could be as far as requesting assistance. He told us he would monitor the frequency for a while to check on our progress.
0410: A large wave came up behind us and slammed the rudder over breaking the steering quadrant and separated from the hull the internal structure of the boat where the steering cable pulleys attach on the starboard side. We contacted W3ZU Fred and asked him to relay a May Day message to the Coast Guard that our situation had deteriorated and that we needed assistance. We then set up the emergency tiller system so we could maintain the boat in a heaved to arrangement to maintain stability.
US Coast Gard Group 11 responded and we informed them of our damages, that the barnacles were reducing our progress and that the bilge pump was keeping up to the ingress of water from the damaged deck.
We also informed them that S/Y CONTINUUM had changed course to meet us. They were going to see if there was another ship in the area that they could ask to assist and we arranged to send regular position reports to them through W3ZU Fred, which we did throughout the night.
7 th April
Pre-dawn: A large wave struck the rudder and broke the emergency steering linkages and the rudder started to swing free to it's stops pounding the hull of the boat.
Sun rise: After day light we lowered the main sail we were still using to stabilize us in the three meter swell and laid out the sea anchor from the bow and there by kept the bow to windward and the rudder out of the main flow of the swells.
We contacted S/Y CONTINUUM as arranged, explained the deterioration of our situation and agreed to meet every two hours on 6.209 Mhz as they progressed towards us.
We were not able to Contact W3ZU Fred as arranged due to poor radio propagation and the S/Y BLUE PELICAN agreed to relay the message of our deteriorating state and that the bilge pump was keeping up with the ingress of approximately one foot of water per hour, through the damaged deck and also in the area of the rudder support which had started to leak due to the force of the rudder striking the hull.
Throughout the day 2 - 3 meter waves continued to slam the rudder into the bottom of the boat as the rudder stops were damaged. We rigged a line from the midship mooring cleats then aft around the rudder to reduce the movement of the rudder and the damage it was imparting on the hull.
With our situation critical but stabilized we continued to pump the bilges every hour to keep ahead of the ingress of water from the damaged bow and the deteriorating condition of the rudder mountings. We maintained radio contact routines with S/Y CONTINUUM, W3ZU Fred and the Seafarer's Net and waited for the arrival of S/Y CONTINUUM.
We were informed by the Seafarer's Net that the S/Y ATHOS OF LONDON had been diverted by RCC Alameda1and was on a course to our location but would arrive after S/Y CONTINUUM.
The US Coast Guard contacted us on 6.290 Mhz and informed us that S/Y The Athos of London was diverted to us and would arrive the next day. They also wanted to confirm that we would accept help from S/Y CONTINUUM and that we would scuttle the sinking S/Y NIRVANA NOW to reduce the time it would be a hazard to navigation. Unfortunately ATHOS did not have an SSB radio on board so we were unable to communicate with her until they were within sight, after we boarded CONTINUUM, and then by using the VHF radio which we both had.
8 th April
1500 UTC S/Y CONTINUUM arrived, we launched our dingy from the deck and managed to mount the out board engine on it in the swells which had increased to 3-4 metes. We loaded the dingy with our documents and a few personal belongings and transferred to the S/Y CONTINUUM successfully due to their seamanship skills and bravery in the rough seas.
We left NIRVANA NOW sinking at position 07 54' S, 119 11' W.
ATHOS OF LONDON arrived about two hours later and offered to assist in any way they may. They informed RCC Alameda1 that we were safe aboard S/Y CONTINUUM, and of the state of S/Y NIRVANA NOW. It was decided for us to remain on, and progress with, S/Y CONTINUUM as opposed to risking another transfer at sea to join the ATHOS.
20th April
We checked in to the Marquesas and gave a statement to the Gendarmarie of the sinking and rescue.
I would like to express my sincere gratitude for the efforts of RCC Alameda1 and their radio watch keepers for their unreplaceable efforts.
Bob and Mona Jankowski on the S/Y CONTINUUM willingly endured great hardship as they motor-sailed 40 hours into strong winds and large seas while standing watches of two hours on/two hours off to enable them to reach us before we sank. The two hour watch routine made possible the radio contact schedule of every two hours which kept them informed of our position as we drifted disabled. It was a great moral booster to us to be to talk to our saviors on a regular basis.
I would like to impress upon all that it was the communications allowed us through the SSB radio giving us access to the land based ham networks and other boats that saved our lives. With the popularity and attributes of satellite phones increasing I think it is still prudent for all persons voyaging off shore to be skilled in the use of the SSB radio.
We will miss the boat that gave us so much joy for 18 years.
Randoll N Ortiz, owner/Captain, S/Y NIRVANA NOW
 

Kleis

.
Mar 12, 2006
10
Hunter 460 Hamilton, Ontario
Praise God for their rescue, communication devices and helping hands. Thanks for sharing!
 
Sep 20, 2014
1,330
Rob Legg RL24 Chain O'Lakes
I really like reading tales of survival, as it seems one can learn more from real stories, than just hearing from the experts. Not that there is not a place for experts, but nothing compares to real life. You get more of a sense of how stuff works.
 
Feb 17, 2006
5,274
Lancer 27PS MCB Camp Pendleton KF6BL
This is great news, but sad for the loss of their boat. And kudos for Ham Radio as it seems to always be there when one really needs it.
 
Aug 31, 2007
296
Catalina 30 Petoskey, Mich.
Thank you Stu for the link, nice to see the faces of the people that saved Randy and Dawn.
 
May 24, 2004
7,213
CC 30 South Florida
Wow, what an ordeal and what a heroic effort from Bob and Mona JanKowsky to reach them in time. Curious about the model and make of the boat and the type of rig; it obviously met its structural design limits during the pounding it took for over three days. Information like this may prevent other owners from a similar mishap. There was also a decision made to run in front of weather. This latter caused a large overtaking wave to incapacitate the rudder. We could perhaps consider alternatives that would lessen structural stress on the boat without further exposing any inherent weaknesses. There is always something to be learned from analyzing these occurrences.
 
Feb 17, 2006
5,274
Lancer 27PS MCB Camp Pendleton KF6BL
Just for information, the boat was located around 07 54' S, 119 11' W, basically in the middle of no where. The contact station helping was located in Inverness, Fl. As the radio waves fly, that is 3500 miles. Now, think about this for a second. Your boat is sinking and you are helped by a guy located 3500 miles away in Florida. That is truly something to think about.
 
May 24, 2004
7,213
CC 30 South Florida
I believe I found my answer in Stu's posting of a link. Nirvana was a 1982 S&S 42' which is capable boat and the Captain and Crew were experienced sailors. We all know the strain that beating into high seas can place on a rig. The fact that the hull was being fouled by marine growth not only affected speed but likely added strong forces to those imparted by the seas. In any instance whatever the design limits or the state of maintenance and age were exceeded causing a breach in the deck/hull joint at the bow. It seems that until the breach was discovered there was no indication of a problem except for the loss of speed. With no indication of problems the Captain may have pressed on. I have sailed old boats and learned that in adverse conditions there was a need to protect them by diminishing as much as possible the forces working against it. Cannot really expect the old fellow to perform as if it was new. I was not there and will not 2nd guess the decision to turn the boat around and run ahead of weather but it is always a decision not to be taken lightly especially with a fouled bottom and rig. I would say heaving to or even going to bare poles is a less aggressive option but all options would depend on the size of the breach. The loss of steering was fatal. Did not hear of any consideration given to deploying a life-raft. Why? Any boat big or small new or old should carry one when crossing the Pacific. I hear a lot of questions about production boats being sturdy enough to cross Oceans and this might be a god example to help explain how the force of the sea can tear apart a boat. I guess my point is that no matter what kind of boat you are sailing whether old or new that the best course of action is to try and preserve the boat by yielding to the strength of the sea without exposing the boats inherent weak areas.
 
Oct 26, 2008
6,432
Catalina 320 Barnegat, NJ
The loss of steering was fatal. Did not hear of any consideration given to deploying a life-raft. Why? Any boat big or small new or old should carry one when crossing the Pacific.
There was no mention, but I suspect that they were in a stable situation on board their boat, despite the fact that they were disabled. It sounds like they were able to keep ahead of the water ingress by pumping. I would guess that old adage of staying with the boat was still in play at the time. They had power, supplies and communication, must of which would have been forfeited or much more limited if they had submitted to a life raft at a time when they weren't quite in eminent danger of sinking.

I'm sure it was a heart-breaking moment when they had to scuttle her.
 
Sep 28, 2008
922
Canadian Sailcraft CS27 Victoria B.C.
Afternoon of 6 th: I noticed that the forestay was loose. It is attached to the bow of the boat and the top of the mast to support the mast. Inspection showed that the deck where the forestay attaches had started to part from the hull.
I can not recall seeing a well built boat, any sailboat really for that matter, that has the forestay attached to the deck and not the hull at the bow. That is a disaster waiting to happen.

While the boat is described as an S&S design, she was certainly either modified by someone or badly built originally. The cabin top may be as design but the ports were definitely not designed by S&S.
 

Attachments