Looking for some expertise on a 28 O'day

May 5, 2016
3
Morgan 36 10T 36 Portsmouth
Hello, I was looking for some advice and please be patient, just learning. I'm looking to get a 28ft O'day project boat and was looking for some hull advice. This boat has not seen water in over 10 years and has been sitting on boat stands on soft ground. Along with about a foot of water in the cabin, the keel has appeared to have pushed itself up into the hull. Also, one of the stands (aft port side) looks like it has dented the hull. In anyone's opinion is this project worth it or should I keep looking I only ask because the boat is 2 miles from my house and the owner is asking for nothing. Just curious if it would be worth the money cost in repairs and shipping.

Thanks
 

Attachments

Aug 2, 2005
1,155
Pearson 33-2 & Typhoon 18 Seneca Lake
If you buy (or are gifted) this boat you will end all chance to enjoy sailing. Two or three years from now you will have an ugly hull full of weeds that have been fertilized by shredded $100 bills and over-watered by your tears! Buy a boat you can sail the day you buy it.
 
Jan 27, 2008
3,092
ODay 35 Beaufort, NC
If it's free strip all the parts off it and sell them. Then sell the keel for scrap metal. You might get 50 cents or a buck a pound for scrap metal. Chop up the remaining glass and dispose in a dumpster. Take the proceeds of the parts and buy a boat in better condition.
 

Apex

.
Jun 19, 2013
1,222
C&C 30 Elk Rapids
The keel is encapsulated type, so what you see in damage is severe structural problems. Scrap for parts is likely more work than you would want to deal with as well.
 
  • Like
Likes: brazenarticle
May 5, 2016
3
Morgan 36 10T 36 Portsmouth
Thanks all for your prompt replies. Like I stated before, looking for a project boat in the 30ft range. Other the the obvious craigslist and eBay would anyone have any direction to finding a cruiser to fix up.
 
Aug 2, 2005
1,155
Pearson 33-2 & Typhoon 18 Seneca Lake
Hello CD, Almost any marina or boat storage lot will have several boats that fit the "project" category. All will need obvious work and most will need work that is not initially evident to you. The idea of saving money on your chosen hobby by purchasing a boat you can work on is walking a fine line. If you look through the "Search Forums" feature on this site you will see many, many questions and responses on the "project boat" situation others have considered. Read them.

Your budget and your purpose for the boat are both prime considerations. (1) If your budget is X dollars consider buying a boat in that price range that is in sailing condition. (2) If it is your first boat smaller might be better than a bigger boat. (3) In any case if you enjoy sailing your first boat will probably not be your last boat. (4) Buy a good looking boat and one made by a popular manufacturer so it will be relatively easy to sell when you are ready to choose a different boat. (5) Spend the money (lunch and a beer after checking the boat) to have the boat you want surveyed by a trustworthy, knowledgeable boating friend or, better yet, (about $10 per foot) by a certified marine surveyor. (6) If you want to work on a sailboat offer to help someone who already owns a "project boat". Listen to the stories of work done, work yet to tackle, and money/time spent. Those stories will be eye-openers! (7) Consider a trailer carried boat in the 18 to 22 foot size. Big enough to work on and learn some skills, big enough to stay overnight, small enough to keep on a trailer (perhaps at home), cheaper to repair because all the parts/systems are smaller and simpler. Best Wishes on making a choice that will make your sailing time enjoyable. (BTW: We have owned, repaired, sailed, and sold many boats since 1995. Check our profile info.) 31seahorse
 
Oct 2, 2008
1,424
Island Packet 31 Brunswick, Ga
An oday is an excellent choice for a first boat and project boat. The Oday owners forum here is excellent. Search for a 22 or even a 26 ( my first). They are fun to sail, and with the 26 you can even spend a week or two boat camping with the companion of your choice. Figure a full two years for a good rebuild. Also somewhere where between $10k and 20k. Your labor. Prices are good, they are trailer able ( a big big big big plus) and very fun to sail. Check out my albums for a rebuild of my 26, and the late great "Trinka", an Oday 22, for some examples. Your on the right track. But not the boat near you. Bad bad bad.
image.jpeg
image.jpeg
image.jpeg
 
Apr 19, 2012
1,043
O'Day Daysailor 17 Nevis MN
Personally I love project boats. Although I'd have to agree with much of what others have said, I would also comment that a project boat can be a lot of fun and can help you save a bundle. I've had several and sold them all for more than I had into them. The main thing is to start with, as others have said, a boat that is already sailable, or at least one that you can motor around in. I'm not saying to abandon a boat that can be made sailable withing the first few weeks but I would avoid one that will take several months or years before you can even try it in the water. For a project boat I would recommend a boat that you can sail when you have to opportunity and work on at your leisure. Being able to sail the boat will give you the encouragement to take care of the other things that can make it prettier, easier to handle, faster, more comfortable, etc. I also agree that trailorable boats often make the best project boats but that may depends on your personal situation. Unfortunately the boat in your pictures doesn't fit into this category.
 

MitchM

.
Jan 20, 2005
1,031
Nauticat 321 pilothouse 32 Erie PA
this is NOT the project boat for you. it sounds like standing water has rusted the keel bolts which is a major investment of time money friends beer and and know how to to repair properly. Run away.

by the way last year there was a freshwater 18 ft TANZER at good will in erie PA- SAIL WORTHY and asking $1000 with a trailer. lovely boat, it sold fast. if you want a good 'project boat' start haunting marinas and boat yards and ask around. often there will be unadvertised 'specials' that you can get a for a very reasonable price. at our marina last year an old 25 cape dory in beautiful shape went for $5K -- with engine. the owner had bought a bigger boat and needed to sell fast.

if you're
 
Feb 26, 2004
23,342
Catalina 34 224 Maple Bay, BC, Canada
Figure a full two years for a good rebuild.
Not if you ever want to go sailing.

Really, skippers, it's a personal choice.

I've never bought a boat that would require me to spend more time getting it ready to sail than just sailing it. 35 years doing this.

Do a search on this or any other boating forums on "project boat" and you'll learn a lot.

Your boat, your choice. :)