I agree re Marathon. We've wintered there and like it. Everything is there, boatyard, grocery stores, hospital, West Marine...all within walking distance from city marina. IMHO Key West is a tacky touristy town, but some people love it. My blog includes information about Marathon and Key West. http://dinghytogrocerystorewestfl.blogspot.com/I also recommend Marathon. We spent 3 winters there, really enjoyed it.