Inflatable or Hard Dinghy ???

Oct 31, 2019
24
The inflatable is by far the best choice. You cannot tow a dinghy while
sailing offshore, so if it?s a hard shell it must go on the cabin top. There
it stands a good chance of being damaged or swept away in bad weather and it
takes a big chuck out of the working space. If the hard shell dinghy is
damaged it is not going to do you any good as a life raft. The inflatable on
the other hand is easy to stow out of harms way and will be available to you
as a life raft if you need it.
Robert Gainer
 

ggs382

.
Aug 28, 2000
11
Lorna Doone was sailed around the world with a custom made hard dingy
very securely fastened forward on the mast. The design allowed easy
access of the forward deck and actually provide extra hand support up
forward. In design this solution was adequate for a single-handed
sailor. Having said this, I am intrigued by John Sprague's "Dingy-Tow"
solution for towing an inflatable. With more than one person on board
and the desire to zip around anchorages and explore nooks and crannies
of the shoreline, I have been considering the purchase of an inflatable.

Have a nice day,
Gene Suess
Suess Retail Systems Inc. "SRS"
E-MAIL: genes@...
PHONE: 1-250-382-4431 - FAX: 1-250-382-4451
SALES & SERVICE: 611 DUNEDIN ST., VICTORIA, B.C. V8T 2L7
"SRS" SUPERIOR RETAIL SYSTEMS
 

mphalv

.
Sep 29, 2001
195
One of those discussions that is best done with an agreement to disagree
already in place.

I have owned both and situational needs should dominant. When we were in
the Bahamas with longer distances to go and the larger lobsters further out, a
big inflatable with OB big enough to plane is really cool. For the
relatively intimate harbors of Maine, the hard dinghy with a small OB is good. Of
course if the big OB won't go then you got a long hard row, even the risk of
being blown away(literally).
I think in general, I favor a nesting (for bigger dink in minimal room) hard
dinghy that rows well with a small OB for the further distances.

Here is a thought. How about a nesting hard that would fit over the coach
house of the Vega designed just for the Vega as a personal fit. Dimensions to
fit the Vega. Think of a glove over the hand.

Paul
Bangor Me.
 
Oct 31, 2019
1
That sounds like a great idea. I seem to recall that you were using
a
nesting dinghy.
are the plans for that available, or was that your own invention?
Does your dinghy fit under the boom or do you carry it forward of
the mast?
Dick
 

mphalv

.
Sep 29, 2001
195
Welcome to the Vega group site Dick and Sammy! Hope the repairs to your
Vega are going well and that you will get a chance to do some sailing.

Yes, we did have a nesting dinghy while we were in Florida, in fact, we
still have the same dinghy. We built it in 1985. It is the Danny Greene
designed "Two Bits." We originally saw an ad in the back of Cruising World Magazine
and sent for the plans. I believe you can still get them. Since then he
has come up with some other designs as well.

We put the two halves together while in the water. To hoist the two halves
in and out of the water, we attached a bridle and cranked it up using the
winch on the mast. We stored it forward of the mast. Since this covered up the
forward hatch, we only stored it on deck while sailing offshore. We towed
it the rest of the time.

That dinghy is now 20 years old. We just placed an order for a fiberglass
sailing nesting dinghy called the NN10. It is pricey, but it seems to have
many distinct advantages over our old dinghy, the most important of which is
quick assembly. You can take a look at this design at _www.niccollslite.net_
(niccollslite.net - niccollslite Resources and Information.) . We will let the group know what we think of it
after we have had a chance to try it. We met a serious offshore sailor in
Maine who recently purchased one and he seems to like it. There are many
types of nesting dinghies available now. You can look at various types by using
a search engine and typing in "nesting dinghies."

If we had a lot of money to throw around, we would also like to have an
inflatable with a roll up floor.

Smooth sailing,
Melanie Halvachs
V1826 "Double Fantasy"
 
Nov 8, 2001
1,818
Hi All

Ref the debate on the dinghy I would also propose teh Tinker Tramp. Great little boat and does just about everything. Most stable dinghy I have ever been in. The Tinker Traveller (12 feet) is similar but I found it too heavy and too large. Try and get hold of a Tinker Tramp but even 2nd hand they are expensive. I managed to get one with teh sailing kit and the liferaft kit. Hope this helps.

Regards to all

Steve Birch
 
Nov 8, 2003
166
Thank you to all who replied.

I will consider all of the suggestions,and they are many (several of
which I was unaware even existed).

Thank you all again.

Robert.
SV Moondance
 
Oct 31, 2019
562
Hi Robert;

I use an inflatable dinghy with a 3 1/2 hp outboard.
I used to have a hard shell dinghy; I liked it more because
it trailes better when sailing and is more stable. Though
there is one important factor for any dinghy: it must be
self bailing!

Wilhelm, V-257