our dingy experience
We have a P42 that we've cruised through the S. Pacific. We stick with inflatables. We had a 10 foot Avon that we just upgraded to an 11 foot Avon with a 15 HP Mercury outboard. While we would love the additional performance and ease of beaching of a hard bottom dingy, we just are not willing to give up our deck space for storage. But it's a difficult decision, and the trade-offs can lead one to either choice.We hoist our outboard with a 4:1 block and tackle off of a swinging arm we mounted on our wind generator mast, and mount the O/B on a wooden holder on the SS railing. It has taken that weight through all kinds of weather without any problems.We used to tow our dingy on any passages less than 2 days long. That was until we lost it while coming in through a coral pass where we unexpectedly encountered breaking waves off the stern. The dingy flipped, the tow bridle and safety lines parted and tore the bridle mounts off the dingy, and it was gone. (Amazingly, some Tongan fisherman later found it in the surf on an island 20 miles away and towed it in to the local authorities who returned it to us). So we no longer tow the dingy for anything more than a short day trip. For passages we deflate the dingy and stow it in the forward head shower area where we can secure it. The floorboards go under the bunks.We just couldn't bring ourselves to give up use of the sun deck during long passages. We also use the stern shower while underway, and couldn't bring ourselves to sacrifice it. For short passages, however, we pull the dingy up and set it on the sunpad. Since it weighs only about 100 pounds, my wife and I can get it up there pretty easily.Good luck in your decision. I'm sure you'll be happy with either a hard bottom or inflatable dingy. The P42 is a very comfortable cruiser; enjoy.