Owned a very similer '190 35.5 for 10 years and really enjoyed it. Sailed the boat to the Keys and back and spent a lot of cruising time in the Northeast from Newport to the Chesapeake Bay. I think the legend series has the nicest lines of the Hunters. The boat has some unusual handling characteristics because of the huge main and fractional jib. The fractional rig takes some getting use to but it is convenient and easy to work and handle.
(My opinion) Pros: Good layout, handsome interior, great head/shower space, roomy for its size, spacious aft cabin, terrific headroom, good sailing boat & easy to single hand - IF SET UP PROPERLY! Can fly downwind and will surf. Extremely responsive to helm with very short turning radius. Backs well under power. Nice galley with good drawer storage. Interior wood very nicely done. Perforated toe-rail!! (every boat should be equipped with this feature as far as I'm concerned).
CONS: Light; needs to reef early. Water slaps big time against the transom when tied up with wind aft. (Choose your slip assignment with this in mind. It would drive me bonkers.) Long boom makes stowing the main a chore. There should be a third dutchman line to prevent the aft end of the sail from spilling into the cockpit. If equipped with a small 110 or lapper jib will require a barber hauler for optimum performance to windward. There is an athwart ship grid strut that supports the mast that sticks up a few inches above the floor. This is the reason that the boat has such good head room. I did not find it to be a problem but others might. Water tank in the bow effects boat trim at varing levels of full/empty. Holding Tank: Hunter installed metal tanks that have an effective life span of about 8 - 10 years before the seams start to go. If you smell head odor in the aft cabin it is probably due to this tank. I replaced mine with a plastic tank of a larger 30 gal size. If the jib furling lines come up through the foredeck it can be an area susceptible to water intrusion in the laminate. Have it checked by your surveyor. I would recommend replacing the ProFurl jib furling system.
Would I buy it again? Absolutely. Good Luck.