Heaps of praise for Maine Sail and his excellent thread on using butyl tape. I just finished rebedding all my deck hardware and teak, and it was so much neater than using 3M 4200. Much easier to trim off the ooze-out than the messy clean up with semi-liquids.
Does it work as well?
I soaked down my entire deck with a hose and none of the places that showed leakage before we're wet. Even those I had rebedded with 4200. Takes quite a bit more time to do it Maine's way, but I think it's gonna be worth it. As for adhesive holding power, I bedded one of my sliding hatch rails, and attached it to the pop-top, then decided I needed to take it off for some reason. After tugging for quite awhile, decided to just leave it alone and installed the screws.
Hint: The butyl tape is a lot easier to work with when the ambient temperature is below 60*. It doesn't stick to your fingers like it does at higher temps. The downside of that is it takes way longer for it to ooze out for trimming. I'm guessing when I get the boat out into the sun this summer i'll need to trim away a bunch more. I might take a heat gun to the s/s fittings to speed things along.