1 year I had a complete and total failure of my prop spray. I use either Pettit PropCoat #1792 or Interlux Inter Zinc.
Not together, but I alternate every other year or so. It actually comes down to what I have in my paint supplies on the day I’m painting the bottom.
I have been using the same products, year after year but one year I got this:
The only thing I can attribute this failure to was, that year I really got into cleaning the prop. And bringing it back to showroom new shine. It looked marvelous but that is what I got in return.
So now, year after year, using the same two products, I have never had more than 5 or 6 barnacles on the prop and shaft.
Now My prep is, I scrape off any that are there and lightly sand the prop with 150 grit paper. Leaving a roughed up surface of the old paint, getting it almost down to the metal. But never seeing the shining bronze underneath.
It works for me.