Have you banged up your boat?

Status
Not open for further replies.
B

Bill O'Donovan

Backwinding danger

While sailing up the Chesapeake Bay this summer in a 15 mph breeze, we attempted to turn too soon after rounding a buoy at Milford Haven. Even though we were a good 100 feet past, the boat stalled and then backwinded us into a green can. Boy, do they look big close up! I managed to jockey the boat at the last second so it was just a glancing blow, but the lesson learned was to stay way shy of the markers. I came back with some green streaks and the rubrail skewed. A fellow two slips down said, "Nice racing stripes."
 
C

Chris Phillips

That d*#n channel marker!!

While racing this summer we rounded a channel marker on the course and my cousin swung the boat a little too close. With the change in direction and the incoming tide we snared the green reflective panel with the backstay! The boat was getting twisted and I watched the mast flexing and I thought it was coming down. I had to get in between the boat and the pole and push us back with my legs. The back stay sprung free and the only apparent damage was to the marker as I noticed the chunks of green reflective material in the wire. Not to mention a damaged ego as the ribbing continues to this day! But looking back, it could have been much worse! Always give those markers a wide berth!! Chris H25 "Blue Light Special"
 
J

Jim Slaughter

Give Way!

I was headed out a very narrow channel out of New Port Richey, FL nearing the outer marker with beacon tower when a big commercial deep sea fishing boat came blasting into the channel on the wrong side! I was under sail and had to take quick evasive action as it was obvious this A**hole wasn't going to obey the rules. A hard turn to port caught my jib and pushed me perilously close to the marker beacon. Another hard to starboard and I thought I had it made when the upper tower on the marker caught my upper shroud and dismasted the boat from the shrouds up. The upper half of the mast came to rest on top of the tower. We were held fast. After a mad scramble to take care of the sails (luckily they weren't damaged), I had to tie off to the marker piling and drop a stern anchor. After untangling the rigging from the tower I was able to lower the top half of the mast to my first mate. The worst part of this whole fiasco is the captain of the fishing boat knew what he had done. He stopped briefly in the channel about 100 yards away and then took off again. I guess his insurance wasn't paid up. Mine was...with a $500 deductible!
 
J

Jim Slaughter

Danged Rudder!

The first time I took out my newly acquired 26D I knew why everybody cusses MacGregor for the rediculously unresponsive and inadequate rudder! I was coming into MY dock behind my house like I had countless times with my Mac 25 when the danged rudder was not responsive enough to turn and I hit the concrete seawall putting a small gouge in the coaming. I should have known better since I had had a terrible weather helm problem all day and almost ended up on the rocks out in Tampa Bay once. Needless to say, I'm making a new rudder for the 26D when I get a chance! MacGregor could make a fortune selling better rudders for these boats! Hey! Anyone listening?
 
H

HENRY HEATH

WHITE LIGHTENING

After a lovely evening at anchorage in South River near Oriental, NC we were returning to port Memorial Day with several other boats when we were struck by lightening during storm with wind gusts to 60 MPH and 4-5 foot waves. Lost VHF antenna, depth readout, TV, CD/stereo, auto-pilot, electric motor on head and MSD. Our 34'Hunter named ABSOLUT may have her named changed to WHITE LIGHTENING if it happens again. That was the second time we had been caught in a storm in the same location but only one lightening hit.
 
T

Tom Ehmke

3 for l

Three seasons ago during a violent thunderstorm which blew through the Western Basin on Lake Erie, we were anchored in the North Bay at Kelley's Island. It is not sheltered at all from the north and the storm came through from the northwest. My decision was to put my first mate ashore and ride the storm out at anchor. After dropping her off at the state park shelterhouse, I motored back to the boat, secured the dingy, started the engine, put on my foul weather gear and listened to the weather reports. When the storm first hit, the boat stood up to the gusts and I was feeling very secure, but when the waves built to 4'-6' in a very short time, the boat went adrift. I will never know if the anchor rode snapped or if the anchor dragged. What I was dealing with was a lee shore over my shoulder and a 10hp Westerbeke trying to hold its own in the wind and waves. Several times it appeared that I was going to beat the surf , but every time I would make a little headway, the storm would turn me beam to the waves and I would be pushed toward the shoreline. This went on for what seemed like an eternity, but what was actually about twenty minutes. I even saw the sun coming out just as I felt the first bump. The wind let up, but the surf pushed me further and further toward the shore and I sat helpless while she bumped along and eventually lay pretty much on her side. The storm was over so everyone who had watched a number of boats being washed ashore were all out to see if boats and crews were ok. Several guys came out to help me flip the dink right-side up and after we cut the tangled anchor rode, we used it to try to pull the boat off. By this time, the surf was about gone, and the boat was aground with no chance to move it by timing our tug-of-war with the wave crests. Someone suggested that we try to lift and push it with his Kubota tractor, so he drove it out into the (now shallow) water and we tried unsuccessfully to lift and pull. Here is where the first damage occurred. Lifting a boat with a small tractor while both are on a soft sand bar is a recipe for trouble, but being a thrifty soul, I decided what the heck, maybe it'll work and I won't have to call BoatUS. The bucket put some nice gouges in the transom. OK, so now it's time to call Boat US. While we waited for the tow, I packed up the dink and cleaned the outboard up. The towboat got us off the bar, but not without a few hard bumps. The keel joint was compromised and we began to take on some significant water. My first mate decided that we were going to find a slip at the marina on the south side and wait the night and any further storms out. Sometimes it's best not to challenge the mate's logic... so we tied up at the fuel dock, compliments of the Seaway Marina. Did I mention that we were taking on water? It was while settling in that I discovered that the automatic bilge switch was no longer working. I ordered the mate to share the watch with me and on the half hour we were to alternate pumping the bilge with the manual switch. She slept like a baby. I was up every half hour pumping the bilge until we sailed back to our home marina in the a.m. for a haul out and keel repair.. So much for the chain of command... And now to end this tale with a bit of irony, while we were getting situated, a cigarette boat came along side. Being courteous sailors, we asked if we could help the driver tie off. He staggered around in the boat, found an orange electrical cord, and after lighting a cigarette, tossed the cord to us, explaining that he had driven through the storm in his brand new boat. He was three (or four) sheets to the wind. There is no justice in the world. His wife and two daughters came up a short time later and she explained that there was no way that she was going to ride in that boat across the lake from Detroit in a thunderstorm... Smart woman. She drove to Sandusky and took the ferry out to Kelley's. We were on the hard for about three weeks in July while repairs were made. He drove his boat back to Detroit the next morning.
 
J

Joris Hitt

Vessel Assist, Vessel Assist, over...

I was coming around the west end of catalina island which was a new way for me and became a little lazy on my navigation. I had checked the charts about a mile before my anchorage and felt comfortable with the approach I would use to the anchorage. I handed the helm to a great sailing friend and started dropping sails etc getting ready to moore when I noticed we weren't heading the way I intended. All of a sudden I saw kelp coming up very quick and signaled to spin and head back the other way. Just as the boat started to spin I was thrown to the deck. I never got a chance to even get my hands in front of me. Anyway the windlass stopped the forward motion of my face sliding along the deck. We had hit a submerged rock and hard. We didn't hang up and we spared the rudder in the process. Jumping below decksI could see my cabinets were displaced and water was coming in. I got us into the mooring, tied up and dove over to see 6000lbs of keel hanging from the hull as well as fiberglass flotsam. Underwater divers, splashzone, 80 miles of hourly check ins to vessel assist and alot of luck and we made it home. 40k in damage, but she's better than new and I'm ready to go again...this time without letting vessel assist know. Joris Offshore Options
 
M

Mike

maiden voyage

I had just purchased and launched my first "big" boat, an O'day 23. I bought her while she was on the hard, so this was the first time I was aboard while afloat. After launching, I was motoring to my temporary slip. I thought I was shifting the engine into reverse as I gingerly approached the dock, but actually had not shifted out of forward. Zoom, the bow gave the dock a good smack. In my semi-panic to get away, I scraped the entire port side along a nearby piling. Once free, I regrouped and carefully (and quite nicely) docked. Upon checking for damage, I discovered not even a scratch in the gelcoat. Of course, the entire episode was observed by a group of boatyard workers across the narrow channel. They had the good manners to appear sympathetic.
 
D

Dick Horton

Shrouds R Us

Headed IRISH ROOTS, my 23 ft MacGregor Venture, out of the club on the Hudson River in a stiff breeze for a photo shoot. Just got the main and self tending jib up and was on a port tack when there was a loud "POP"! I looked up to see the upper shroud on the port side dangling. I immediately let the main sheet fly and came about to get the pressure off the mast. Then was able to drop both sails and motor back to the club without loosing the mast. So much for the photo shoot. Another shroud incident could have been worse, but luck was with me. I was on a circumnavigation of Long Island and was about 5 miles out in the Atlantic when I noticed the starboard lower shroud stretching at the lower fitting because of a couple of broken strands of wire. I immediately went on to a port tack to relieve the pressure and try to figure out what to do. Fortunately I am the world's biggest pack-rat and rummaging through my many boxes of "stuff" I came up with some cable clamps and a piece of old shroud wire that I had saved. I added some rope to the patch in case the cable clamps slipped and was able to effect a good enough repair to complete the trip uninterrupted by a stop at a yard to replace the shroud. Now I make sure the shrouds are inspected regularly and that I have repair parts on board.
 
S

stefan oetter

damaged

once, when coming out of the gulf islands..I hit an underwater shoal..i had already pulled up the centre board...but the rudder cable snapped like dry spaghetti..i had to limp home across the straight with the rudder pointing out at a 90 degree angle...rough seas and no control!
 
M

Michael Bell

Watching the seals

While in the Desolation Sound area, we saw a small island covered with seals sunning themselves. The kids wanted a closer look – so with a quick glance at the chart, I swung by. Unfortunately, what I thought was a dot indicating the island in view was actually beside it (and just submerged). Our center board was up and we were under power at about 4 knots when we hit. My youngest, standing by the cabin-way door went flying into the cabin. The bow of the boat rose about two feet higher than the aft. I panicked of course, ready to hail a mayday. No one was hurt and we were not taking on water, but I couldn’t get the boat off the rock (26’ w8hp outboard). It was the first time in my sailing experience that I was delighted to see a motorboat coming. Between the both of us, we got it off the rock and he was kind enough to stay around while we checked for leaks – then took our picture. Later inspection at haul out showed the boat had landed on the front edge of the (raised) centerboard. I think most of the damage was caused by my grinding the boat back and forth in reverse, attempting escape. I watch the charts, and my chartplotter much more closely now. And, I learned how to do minor fiberglass repair.
 
B

Bob

Watch out for that seawall!

This actually happened on my prior boat, a Columbia 34 Mk II. The second time a I used the boat, the transmission cable shapped...while engaged in reverse! Thinking I was in forward and needed 'just a little boost', I supplied a little more throttle. Well, at least I only hit the seawall, and didn't take out any other boat. The cable had been mentioned on the survey, but I had ignored it. You better believe I revisited the survey and had every noted item rechecked.
 
B

Bob Fair

Watch for Clements reef!

Second time out in our '98 MAC26X I"misread" the chart off the east side of Sucia island. There was a white balloon thingy way off to strbd while we were under full sail, but I judged us to be well clear of the drying rocks east of Clements reef - WRONG. My wife kept asking me to check sounder - rapid shift from 80 feet to 16 feet then 2 feet - BANG!! Centerboard hit! Wife pulled it up. I saw rocky bottom just below us. Let all sails go and before I could untie rudders, the port rudder hit then bang, the fairlead broke thereby releasing the rudder tension! A loud scraping noise from the hull - later found to be a scratch in the gelcoat but no penetration of fiberglass. I started up motor and got the heck out of there.Later that year (2000) the white balloon was replaced by a proper "HAZARD" marker. I wonder how many boats lost their keels on that one. Aftermath - I filled the scratch with white epoxy and sanded it smooth. This year I bottom painted her black so no sign of our error. Read the chart and give her a wide berth!
 
S

steven f.

CRAB POTS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

At night those suckers are a real drag, especially if running the engine! Hate cutting the fishman's lines but sometimes its just unavoidable. Sorry to all you crabber's out there, its not done on purpose.
 
D

david Mccollough

Not as bad as it could be

Sitting at home the other day and rec'd that dreaded call from the marina. A Shrimper up the creek from the marina lost his engine during an outgoing tide. We get up to an eight foot tide so its really something to reckon with in the creeks around Savannah. Naturally it didn't occur to this guy to drop an anchor, he just used my hunter 33 as a fender. Worked really well for him, his pride was the only thing hurt. My poor boat didn't fare that well but she didn't pop like a balloon. The damage appears superficial but I worry about the integrity of the fiberglass. People that saw the mishap saw the hull flexing. Guess I'll find out the next time I try the pass in foul weather.
 
B

Brian Stevenson

Not Too Serious

Flag Island, right on the border, a long long time ago, I misread a series of buoys and sailed up a sloping shoal( maybe the only benefit of ice). It was a gradual stop from about 3 kts,and no one was hurt. I quickly recalled my graduation from the Power and Sail Sqdrn. course, when the Commodore asked" what is the first thing you do when you have a collision?" to which I replied "check for injuries, check to see if you're taking on water!" And in front of the hundred or so sailors he answered" NO,take down the P
 
S

Steven Schultz

First Race Collission

1993 The crew I was racing with finaly talked me into racing my own boat. Seas were fair with boat speeds in the 4-5 knot range. An Ericson 30 that was undermanned jibed around behind another boat right on the starting line and didn't see me until too late. he t-boned me right on the port side stanchion at the aft end of the house. He snapped the lifeline and turned the stanchion into the shape of a winch handle. He left a hole about a foot and a half long right at the rail as his bow slid back he sheered the pushpit off and if he had been 6" further on board would have caught the backstay and taken the mast downI was able to have the boat repaired at the dock as good as new (invisible) and upgraded to the double rail pushpit. The boat has been very successfully raced since that time
 
S

SailboatOwners.com

Final results

Final results for the Quick Quiz ending 11/19/01: Have you damaged your boat while underway? 51% No 17% Yes, while docking 16% Yes, grounding or obstructions 16% Yes, other cause
 
H

Howard R.

Swing to FULL

Sailing on Old Hickory lake here in Nashville, that I have hundreds of miles logged on (on my Catalina 25 swing keel). I was sailing one night in the Catalina 30 I just bought this year and traveling up the bank when I came to a sudden stop. AGROUND! Just knew it.I tossed out the anchor and waited till morning. Had a guy in a bass boat pull me out a little ways and threw the anchor back out. Went below, made coffee and breakfast. Wind was blowing about 15 knots. I pulled the anchor up and took my time about getting back to the cockpit even though I wasn't that far from the bank I had sailed alot closer to it over the years. When I unfurled the genie I went about 50 yards and AGROUND again. Vertually the same spot. I will sail a little different with this boat than I did my 25 swing keel, I can tell that already....
 
S

Steven Schroeder

Backed the vanged main

Coming back from Block this past July, 15 knots or less but in a heavy sea off of Pt. Judith. Tide was with us but does funny things there. We were motorsailing to make time due to the sea with the main prevented with a vang to the rail. Large power boat came down on us not oaying attention, on auto pilot, etc. Had to jibe, but of course only the top of sail jibed
 
Status
Not open for further replies.