Good Old Boat of the Year: results!

Status
Not open for further replies.
T

Tom Ehmke

Todd Alt, how the heck are you?

This is the first time I've seen your name on a post here. Are you still at NEPort? Last time I recall seeing you was two years ago at Leamington. We're still sailing our 272 and docking at Harbor Park. What's new with you? Tom
 
P

Paul Koestner

Please continue, Todd

I'm not disagreeing with your assertion, Todd. I think I know where your response gets its inspiration. But for those who may be wondering, how would your vote affect the outcome? Let's hear the slamdance version. On my end, My wife and I looked for a couple years to find the "right boat" for us. Much of that discovery involved defining "us", which is to say, what we thought we wanted in a boat. We were interested in the "coastal cruising" category, and after owning a smaller boat (Hunter 25) for a while, then sailing larger boats and looking at lots of other boats, I mean lots, we were convinced that our boat had not been built yet (at least not in our price range), but the closest that came to our mind's eye was the Catalina 30. Interesting to see it chosen as best in "our" class. Life, of course, is what happens to you when you're busy making other plans, and we bumped into a Morgan 34. We are thus far thrilled with the challenge of adapting our dream to this 1970 reality. Which category would you rework, and why? I value your opinion as much as I value those of the editors of GOB Magazine, if only because you sail on one of the Great Lakes, and I'm origiinally from Michigan and miss the smell of fresh water. Give us your list, Todd. And if anybody has a question about Deb's and my boat, give us a shout at dpkoestner@mac.com, since I'm old enough to know that our Morgan 34, lovely and functional though she is, will only be our last boat if I croak before her iron genny does.
 
D

Douglas G Young

Could not agree less

I could not agree less with the artical. I think the main thing is what qualifies as a good old boat. I would not have even considered a Mac. Even the Catalina 30 is pushing the envelope. Perhaps there needs to be a way of qualifying (good old boat) a hall of fame so to speak. Not centered around what Mfg produced the most boats or what you could find the most of.
 
T

Tom

Doug, The C30 in American Sailboat Hall of Fame

That isn't saying its the BEST 30 footer out there. Just that there are too many redeeming qualities and it has provided many people good sailing moments over the years (over 8000 built and many people still enjoying them today). Thats gotta say something. I think there is only about 20 sailboats inducted into this hall of fame. Link is below
 
T

Tom Ehmke

Please... read the article before you go off

on Good Old Boat. It is a gigantic, hilarious, tongue-in-cheek spoof of the sailing rags which are 90% advertising and contain an annual boat of the year article. Although the results were generated by sailors who voted at this website, it is, in my opinion, no more than an (intentionally) flawed popularity contest done to satirize the glossy sailing mags. What the article concludes is that all of our boats are good old boats and we should all enjoy them. Some of you have fallen into the trap set by the folks at Good Old Boat which poked fun at the "serious" reviews which lead to Boat Of The Year awards in other magazines. Bottom line... enjoy your boat!!! Tom
 
Status
Not open for further replies.