Garmin vs Navionics

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jan 22, 2008
1,483
Hunter 37 C sloop Punta Gorda FL
I finally figured out how to download and pay for the Garmin Blue charts for my Ipad. Problem was operator error (me). Anyway yesterday we went sailing in 85 degree light air . Sorry Yankees. ran both Garmin and Navionics. Pictures came out lousy (me again). Attached are posed photos at home so there are no speed course data on either.

We are not affiliated with either, we are not professionals. We are both experienced amateur boaters. Unanimously we like Navionics, but it's details, techniques. Both work. Both work well. We did not experience any delays loading tides in either app. Navionics shows speed in BIG numbers at the upper right. Garmin Smaller numbers in a dashboard kind of thing at the bottom. Garmin also shows heading in small numbers in the dashboard. Navionics has a bright red line extending from your boat in the direction you are heading, no numbers. Garmin seemed dull dingy, might be better at night. I have no experience, but have read that navionics is too bright at night. We did not find the Active Captain icons intrusive, but I have seen that complaint written. In our local area, there is a gap in the Garmin depth data. Navionics has the entrance channel to our canal all wrong.

Navionics is now nearly $50 I bought the $30 Garmin Package, not the $44 one. As Practical Sailor says, this is just the first release. Things can only get better

Nobody needs both of these, but I'm kind of a navigation groupie. Navionics left, Garmin Right
 

Attachments

Last edited:

Tim R.

.
May 27, 2004
3,626
Caliber 40 Long Range Cruiser Portland, Maine
I have Navionics on my Android phone and Garmin on my ipad. I am waiting til spring to purchase nav charts for Garmin in case they do an update between now and then.

The thing I hate about the Navionics and it may be different on the ipad is when you zoom an area, the soundings get bigger for and instant and then revert back to their tiny font which I cannot easily read without reading glasses.

I am also a navigation junkie and I use these apps for general awareness when on other boats or when I am sitting on the rail and cannot see either of my dedicated chartplotters.
 
Nov 8, 2010
11,386
Beneteau First 36.7 & 260 Minneapolis MN & Bayfield WI
I like the Navionics app, but it can be almost USELESS for sailors on many inland lakes. Why?

Navionics does their own, highly vaunted 1-foot surveys of many US lakes. Fisherman, their primary audience by far, love this because they can come in slow with their trolling motors, and see very detailed views of breaks and cover.

The sad part is you cannot turn off this detail, and the mass of contour lines often turns the map solid black at most zoom levels. Here's Lake Minnetonka where BlueJ lives. Make sense at a glance to you??

 
Status
Not open for further replies.