Effects of disconnecting hydronic heater

Apr 5, 2009
3,146
Catalina '88 C30 tr/bs Oak Harbor, WA
You said that you removed the hydronic heater and plugged the hoses. The cabin and water heaters needed to be in-line with one of the coolant circuits (by-pass or primary). Based on your photo, it appears to be in the by-pass circuit. When you plugged the two hoses you stopped all coolant flow in the by-pass circuit which not a good thing. You need to join the two hoses together to allow the coolant to flow.
A completely blocked by-pass should not cause overheating of the engine once it is fully warmed up but can defiantly cause problems while the engine is coming up to heat because the thermostat is not getting water flow from the engine. The only flow that it will get is through the tiny hole in the thermostat that is designed to let out air bubbles when you fill the system.
As jssailem said, your removal of the water and cabin heaters, in essence removed two heat exchangers from your system which would supplement the cooling in the raw water heat exchanger and mask a partial blockage there.
 
  • Like
Likes: baycloud
Mar 4, 2019
140
Hunter 40.5 Baja
You said that you removed the hydronic heater and plugged the hoses. The cabin and water heaters needed to be in-line with one of the coolant circuits (by-pass or primary). Based on your photo, it appears to be in the by-pass circuit. When you plugged the two hoses you stopped all coolant flow in the by-pass circuit which not a good thing. You need to join the two hoses together to allow the coolant to flow.
A completely blocked by-pass should not cause overheating of the engine once it is fully warmed up but can defiantly cause problems while the engine is coming up to heat because the thermostat is not getting water flow from the engine. The only flow that it will get is through the tiny hole in the thermostat that is designed to let out air bubbles when you fill the system.
As jssailem said, your removal of the water and cabin heaters, in essence removed two heat exchangers from your system which would supplement the cooling in the raw water heat exchanger and mask a partial blockage there.
My latest theory is that these hydronic systems' particulars or a bad thermostat is at fault. I did connect the hydronic heating hoses together but didn't feel any heat in expansion tank #1 after 10 minutes of running with a low load. However a second expansion tank was indeed hot.

So in my estimation I need to trace the hydronic lines/look for valves, verify the hydronic connection locations are correct for this engine, and verify the thermostat is working properly. Lastly make sure there are no air bubbles - my overflow tank above the engine had always been empty, but the heat exchanger is always full.
 
Apr 5, 2009
3,146
Catalina '88 C30 tr/bs Oak Harbor, WA
... Lastly make sure there are no air bubbles - my overflow tank above the engine had always been empty, but the heat exchanger is always full.
Air in the system is a problem because depending on the flow and differential pressure from the pump, an air bubble will act like a valve and will let little or no coolant flow.

On my system, I have air bleed screws at 3 locations and can visually check the flow at the expansion tank. My system has manual valves to direct coolant to the heat coils, water heater and engine or Espar heater.

There are (4) open/close ball valves and a 3-way value to control everything. And a check list and spread sheet to help me remember how it all works! That is on a system that I designed and built myself.

I feel your pain trying to figure out a system that is unknown to you.
 
  • Like
Likes: baycloud