PNW Weather
Hi Ken, we've been sailing PNW waters for years and have had both. We cruise year around and have settled on some things that work for us. If you are into sailing rather than motor sailing, a full cockpit enclosure makes things a bit difficult when it comes to making tack changes, trimming, etc. Likewise, weather can get dicey at times, so a boat without a dodger makes cockpit time miserable in a snow storm even with foulies.
Our boat is equipped with a dodger and bimini, plus I keep foulies on board. So, when weather turns sour, at least I have the protection of the two. During the summer the bimini helps with sun exposure. When you're at the helm for a few hours in the sun, the bimini shade makes matters much more comfortable.
As far as the other stuff goes, we have an oven, three burner CNG stove, diesel forced air furnace, freezer, refrigerator, etc. That way we can cruise for months on end and still have the comforts that make for a pleasant time on board.
Lots of boats with the amenities that you need or want. Belle-Vie is our second Hunter and would do it again with no regrets. We've sailed her all over PNW waters including several two month cruises and regular winter cruises, even some in snow storms.
Some people like the full cockpit enclosure. Our first boat had one and I sailed with it once on a lumpy day from Poulsbo to Everett in a southerly. I did not like the enclosed echoey feeling. I much prefer just the dodger and bimini with foulies if necessary.