Cuttyhunk, Hadley Harbor and Martha's Vineyard

Ariel

.
Feb 1, 2006
279
Pearson 36-2 Houston, TX / Rock Hall, MD
A recent article in Cruising World magazine about sailing around southern New England reminded me of a similar cruise that Lois and I made several years ago. Here is our take of that cruise that I wrote for our sailing club newsletter.

If you are stuck in the snow and cold of this miserable winter, maybe this will improve your mood. Hope you enjoy it.

CRUISE TO PLACES PAST BY

In past years we have cruised to Maine and New England with specific destinations. Because of time or weather, we by-passed many places that we would have liked to stop and see. Our summer cruise in 2008 was to go back and visit these anchorages and harbors that we had sailed by in the past. Of course the route included many places that we really enjoy, like New York City, Jamestown, RI, and Milford and Stonington, CT. In addition, we found even more that were as beautiful and fun as we had imagined, like Cuttyhunk Island, Hadley Harbor, and Edgartown. And of course, the sailing to get there and back was interesting and challenging.


Little Cuttyhunk Island turned out to be one of those story book places. Positioned at the western end of the Elizabeth Islands that separate Buzzards Bay, Vineyard Sound and the North Atlantic, it usually gets passed by as it is off the route to Block Island, Newport or New Bedford. A one hour walk from the islands small harbor, the one paved road leads to the highest point on the island where you look out over the eastward running archipelago and the surrounding waters, and the distinctive cliffs of Martha’s Vineyard. Along the road is the Cuttyhunk Fishing Club. Founded in 1894, the club is almost exactly as it was when William Howard Taft and President Teddy Roosevelt came here on a fishing trip. That was the last bit of excitement for the fifty or so residences of the island until Ariel arrived with Lois on board. Well, there could have been some other excitement, but no one mentioned it. The boat Raw Bar, begins its round of the boats moored in the harbor about 6:00 PM each day and the owner sells fresh oysters and clams from his local beds, along with great chowder and shrimp.
There is nothing like oysters harvested only an hour earlier and shucked in front of you for an easy, no mess dinner. That alone was worth the trip. We stopped at Cuttyhunk both going and returning it was so good.

Hadley Harbor is a beautiful cove in Naushon Island, at the eastern end of the Elizabeth Islands, and the last island in the chain before it ends at Cape Cod. The harbor is a totally protected natural refuge and to keep order among the anchored boats, the Naushon Trust (founded by the Forbes family, owners of the islands) has set moorings, available at no cost on a first-come first-served basis.The scenery is as beautiful as the coves of Maine, with a boat yard complete with beautiful Herreshoff sloops tied to the docks and a real marine railway to haul the wooden boats. Tied to a mooring and without any worries of dragging anchors or thunder storms that might arrive unexpectedly in the dark of night, it’s not hard to dream of the Victorian age and the wives awaiting the return of their men from the fishing grounds off Cape Cod and the George’s Banks. It is really a magical place and well worth a stopover.

Leaving Hadley Harbor, you have to transit Woods Hole to get to the islands of Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket. The tidal currents in Woods Hole make the currents of Hell Gate in the East River feel like child’s play. A mistake in Woods Hole means you can easily be swept onto very hard rocks that lurk just under the water at mid tide. (The “Hole” in these parts refers to the passage between the islands. There are four holes that form passages between the Elizabeth Islands, Woods Hole being the busiest. Two of the holes are very dangerous to use unless the seas are benign and you have local knowledge. To further confuse the issue, there is also the town of Woods Hole, home of the famous marine research center.) We passed through the hole without problems, timing the tide correctly and, luckily, picking a morning without fog. The sail through Vineyard Sound was calm and very quick with a favorable tide. The distances between the ports on Martha’s Vineyard are very close and it’s only a short time before you pass Vineyard Haven, Oak Bluffs and Edgartown. Lining the Edgartown harbor are gracious homes of long ago sea captains and the unspoken tales of whale oil, mutinous crews and wooden ships lost in the cold waters while the wives paced the widow’s walks above the homes. Many of these houses are now the shops that cater to the islands elegant residents and affluent visitors. Edgartown turned out to be a good place to use as a base to see the island with easy bus service to any point. The little town of Oak Bluffs was a surprise. In the 19th century Oak Bluffs was known as the “Cottage City of America” when it attracted Methodists from all over the country for the Martha’s Vineyard Camp Meetings. They came to pray and preach, setting up their tents at this seaside spot. Gradually tiny houses replaced the tents, all gaily painted and adorned with gingerbread and scrollwork.The annual camp meetings continue today. The huge tent was replaced in 1879 by a wood and wrought-iron “Tabernacle” that is still in use. A walk through this now historic area is well worth the stop.

This chronicle would not be complete without telling of our meeting Theo Piper and his wife Maria Piperoglou in New York. Theo and Maria are Greek-Americans who live in Manhattan and have a boat that they are rebuilding, with plans to send it to their seaside home in Greece when they retire in several years. Imagine a modern sailboat with a distinct Greek look. It even has mink covered throw pillows. You will understand that when you read on. After several dinners together and lots of boat discussions, they took us to their favorite Greek restaurant in Astoria along with a tour of some of the more interesting parts of greater New York City. Now, a ride through Manhattan, with a Greek driver that is pointing out all the sights, is a treat in its self. An evening of Greek food was the main treat and was indescribable. As I can’t understand Greek, it really is indescribable, other than to say that it was one of the most enjoyable meals that we have ever had. We soon lost count of the courses as the food just continued to be set on the table. Theo and Maria are furriers and manufacture fur coats for the fashion designers. According to them they are one of the last fur manufacturers in the country, as all have now moved overseas. On a visit to their shop in the garment district, we got a course in fur 101, seeing how they sort the pelts to get uniform color for a coat and how to make a forty-two inch coat from a bunch of sixteen inch long minks. When they retire, they know of no one left to perform this work in the US. There is a story here for somebody and we would not be surprised to see them in the news someday. We will always remember our fun time with them.

If Sam Llewellyn, my favorite Scottish author of nautical mystery stories, were to describe our return trip, he would write that “the sky was high and blue, the barometer was up, the breeze a brisk northerly and the air had a peculiar sparkle as Ariel rolled steadily through the blue swells”. Now, for the reality. The return trip was not as pleasant, with much less wind and a long ocean swell from hurricane Bertha that was over a thousand miles to the east, then a run up Delaware Bay with a tide that was opposing the strong wind and swell blowing in from the sea. You cannot always have fair winds and calm seas.



Dave & Lois
S/V ARIEL
 
Jan 1, 2006
7,943
Slickcraft 26 Sailfish
Thanks for that story. It did brighten my day as I am listening to a "Dire" forecast for yet another snow storm.
We spent a few days fogged in at Cuttyhunk which were very enjoyable. One of the great things about all the destinations mentioned is the plethora of yacht eye candy to see. For a longer version of this story Anthony Bailey's book The Coast of Summer, is an enjoyable read to get ready for a summer cruise.
 

Pat

.
Jun 7, 2004
1,250
Oday 272LE Ninnescah Yacht Club, Wichita, Ks.
Thank you very much for the story. I was born in Wichita, Ks. but spent a wonderful
four years in Newport, R.I. where I met my wife from Darien, Ct. who was attending
college in Newport. I fell in love with New England and in my heart never left, though we have lived in Wichita for many years. While living in Newport, I drove myself all over and explored many of the places you describe. One of our first vacations was a 7 day trip on the Schooner Shenandoah which visited Cuttyhunk and the other places you describe. I was lucky enough to spend a month on Nantucket at Eddleton's Guest House on Chestnut Street and will never forget the people I met and the places I visited
on Nantucket..my first night on Nantucket I walked to the Jared Coffin House and the fellow playing piano at the bar had just finished playing at the Wichita Petroleum Club so
somehow, just seemed ordained that I should fall in love with coastal New England. So
many memories for a boy from Kansas to recall on this really cold, snowy morning back in Wichita.. sorry to bore you, but thank you for recounting your trip for us to share.
A chilled Patrick in Wichita.
 

Tom J

.
Sep 30, 2008
2,325
Catalina 310 Quincy, MA
Great story, thanks. Although I'm not hunkered down for the winter, (we went to the beach yesterday), I do miss my boat. She is on the hard, literally, since the ground in New England is frozen like the far North. Cuttyhunk is high on our list for places to visit next season, and we look forward to enjoying it as much as you did.
 
Nov 26, 2008
1,970
Endeavour 42 Cruisin
We've stopped at Cutty and Hadley's a few times. Great places.
One observation we made. In both of these places, in water less than about 12' there is a lot of weeds. You think you're hooked until you set at full throttle or until a storm blows in. Deeper water has good holding. Be careful if you anchor in shallow water!
 

Bob S

.
Sep 27, 2007
1,813
Beneteau 393 New Bedford, MA
Cuttyhunk

If you spend any time in Cuttyhunk I would recommend sailing through Quick's Hole and across Vineyard Sound and spend an evening in Menemsha. Anchoring in the outer harbor with light SW winds which is the prevailing wind can be beautiful. Great little fishing town and the sunsets are amazing. This is the sun setting over Cuttyhunk.
 

Attachments

Tom J

.
Sep 30, 2008
2,325
Catalina 310 Quincy, MA
If you spend any time in Cuttyhunk I would recommend sailing through Quick's Hole and across Vineyard Sound and spend an evening in Menemsha. Anchoring in the outer harbor with light SW winds which is the prevailing wind can be beautiful. Great little fishing town and the sunsets are amazing. This is the sun setting over Cuttyhunk.
Menemsha is a great place to visit. We stopped there last summer in my brother-in-law's 28' Cape Dory trawler. It's important, though, that you check the forecast for winds. Most of the time, the winds in the summer are from the SW and the moorings are in the lee of the island. When we stayed overnight in September, though, the winds switched around to the North overnight. The wind was blowing across the sound, setting up a good chop, but the incoming tide was holding the boat beam-to to the waves. The boat of course was rolling quite a bit in the morning, and we couldn't wait to get off the mooring.
 
Nov 18, 2010
2,441
Catalina 310 Hingham, MA
Menemsha is a great place to visit. We stopped there last summer in my brother-in-law's 28' Cape Dory trawler. It's important, though, that you check the forecast for winds. Most of the time, the winds in the summer are from the SW and the moorings are in the lee of the island. When we stayed overnight in September, though, the winds switched around to the North overnight. The wind was blowing across the sound, setting up a good chop, but the incoming tide was holding the boat beam-to to the waves. The boat of course was rolling quite a bit in the morning, and we couldn't wait to get off the mooring.
You can also use the moorings in the inner harbor too. They will expect you to raft up. The days we were there in 2011 the wind kicked up to 35-45 kts and you would never be able to stay in the outer harbor.
 

Attachments

Nov 26, 2008
1,970
Endeavour 42 Cruisin
I've run aground more than once from bs reports from that website and seen depths much greater than reported as well. It is definitely not reliable. Got any other sources?
 
Nov 18, 2010
2,441
Catalina 310 Hingham, MA
I've run aground more than once from bs reports from that website and seen depths much greater than reported as well. It is definitely not reliable. Got any other sources?
I don't rely on the depths from active captain either. That depth is from vector charts by Navionics
 
Feb 26, 2004
23,312
Catalina 34 224 Maple Bay, BC, Canada
Water depths & activecaptain

I've run aground more than once from bs reports from that website and seen depths much greater than reported as well. It is definitely not reliable. Got any other sources?
Can you be more specific? If I understand JK's post below, then activecaptain is using the same depths on the same charts, right? It would appear that the additional input from skippers "actively" cruising would show up on the charts as posts about varying depths. From everything I've read on cruisersforum, the use of ac is pretty influential, for example, on the east coast ICW, and perhaps the FL panhandle to New Orleans.

I don't rely on the depths from active captain either. That depth is from vector charts by Navionics
Kinda the same question. Have you noticed any differences between raster and vector charts? (assuming both are the latest updates).
 
Nov 26, 2008
1,970
Endeavour 42 Cruisin
The chart overlay is a separate from the posted reports. I assume that quoting that site is quoting the posted reports. In many areas of the icw you will read conflicting reports...deep water is on the green side, best depths are on the red side. I've read reports on the icw of running aground in 4' near midchannel and when I went thru there was 20' in the channel with less than 2' of tide. And twice I went to anchorages reported to be 8' and plowed mud with my 5' keel.
 
Nov 18, 2010
2,441
Catalina 310 Hingham, MA
Can you be more specific? If I understand JK's post below, then activecaptain is using the same depths on the same charts, right? It would appear that the additional input from skippers "actively" cruising would show up on the charts as posts about varying depths. From everything I've read on cruisersforum, the use of ac is pretty influential, for example, on the east coast ICW, and perhaps the FL panhandle to New Orleans. Kinda the same question. Have you noticed any differences between raster and vector charts? (assuming both are the latest updates).
Post Hurricane Sandy there are many changes, most of the slight, that aren't reflected in older charts and in the listed depth in the general information for a particular marina.

Here is a couple of shots of the entrance to Kennebunkport. From the info it looks good for our 5 foot draft. But when you call chick's marina they tell you there is a shoal that you have to time with a 5 foot draft. So we do have some inconsistencies.

I have also run aground in soft mud when the bottom was shown to be 8-10 feet. It happens. Charts aren't perfect.
 

Attachments

Bob S

.
Sep 27, 2007
1,813
Beneteau 393 New Bedford, MA
Jesse,
Correct me if I'm wrong but I believe there are only three moorings in the inner harbor that fill up early. Also, anyone attempting the inner harbor should only do so at slack tide. The currents entering are very strong and there isn't much room. Personally, I prefer to anchor outside in the bite but only go there when the winds are predicted to be light. It's a very quiet part of the Vineyard. I love Lake Tashmoo when the winds are up but I only draw 3'10".

Appreciate Dave and Luis's post to warm my thoughts. Woke up to 12° with winds it feels like 3°. Highs in the lower 20's. Do you think we might see summer soon? I'm sick of reminiscing.
 
Nov 18, 2010
2,441
Catalina 310 Hingham, MA
Jesse,
Correct me if I'm wrong but I believe there are only three moorings in the inner harbor that fill up early. Also, anyone attempting the inner harbor should only do so at slack tide. The currents entering are very strong and there isn't much room. Personally, I prefer to anchor outside in the bite but only go there when the winds are predicted to be light. It's a very quiet part of the Vineyard. I love Lake Tashmoo when the winds are up but I only draw 3'10".

Appreciate Dave and Luis's post to warm my thoughts. Woke up to 12° with winds it feels like 3°. Highs in the lower 20's. Do you think we might see summer soon? I'm sick of reminiscing.
I wouldn't try to enter at max flow but if you have adequate power you should be fine. I think there are two moorings and you can put two boats on each. I would guess that during peak season they probably go quick. Just like everywhere else around there.

I am also totally sick of this winter. Can't wait for it to be done. But I am glad this wasn't our first winter living aboard full time. Hopefully next winter will be a mild one :)
 
Mar 25, 2014
4
Bowman 46 Yawl Annapolis
Post Hurricane Sandy there are many changes, most of the slight, that aren't reflected in older charts and in the listed depth in the general information for a particular marina.

Here is a couple of shots of the entrance to Kennebunkport. From the info it looks good for our 5 foot draft. But when you call chick's marina they tell you there is a shoal that you have to time with a 5 foot draft. So we do have some inconsistencies.

I have also run aground in soft mud when the bottom was shown to be 8-10 feet. It happens. Charts aren't perfect.
So true!... I have just finished a delivery from the BVI to Key Largo and I used the Navionics Sonar Chart feature on my iPad. WOW! Apparently this is community sourced data that is generating accurate depth information with 1 foot intervals. Best part is it is updated.

Lucky me...I am picking up a new Catalina 470 in Kemah to deliver it to Annapolis. Yup, I will use my ipad as back up!
 
Mar 25, 2014
4
Bowman 46 Yawl Annapolis
Also..almost forgot, there was a concerted effort to re-map the bottom after Sandy using that same Navionics Sonar Chart routine.