Chapman Piloting & Seamanship New-vs-Old

Status
Not open for further replies.

xcyz

.
Jan 22, 2008
174
Hunter 376
How much do these books really change other then references to latest technologies (radar|GPS)? Do you keep current on the latest book revisions? Do you even open the book or is it being used as a Salon table decoration?

I've been sailing for many years and have the 62nd edition. The 66th has been out for a while and wondering what the delta is between the two.

Thoughts?:confused:
 

Les

.
May 8, 2004
375
Hunter 27 Bellingham, WA
I'm delighted with your question of what is different in the most recent chapman's Piloting and Small Boat Handling and may well buy the latest when it is published. Perhaps it will be available for the e-readers and iPads. However i do wish to let you know that there has been a great deal of difference from the early edition of 1917 when it first came out. You would not recognize it from the present edition as it was only 7 by 5 inches in size and less then a half inch thick.

In the 1917 edition there is barely a mention of sailboats other than to keep out of their way. Compass and charts were important and lights had a requirement of lens of fresnel or fluted of 16 square inches. While there is a complete chapter on the compass and its deviations, another chapter deals with nautical instruments....such as the Chip Log (with an Hour Glass) to measure boat speed, the Patent Log for those more wealthy, the Chronometer and the Lead Line. The recommendation was to forty fathoms which meant dropping a line 240 feet. Oh how I like my depth sounder.

But one thing has not changed much in all these years...that of Flags and Colors. I find it interesting that there were owners' flags, owners' dinner flags, guests flags and crew meal pennant. One flag has escaped my understanding and perhaps some of you can help....that flag being "the night pennant". For what reason would you fly that flag? I wonder.....

I suspect the newest edition will have something to say about iPads and apps and probably a fair amount about piloting using the latest GPS screens and hopefully it will also talk about AIS, automated Identification system. There has been many changes since 1917 when Motor Boating published the first little book in our sport.

Thanks for the question--I'll be looking forward to the latest publication...hopefully on my iPad (it won't weight as much as the hard bound edition.).
 
Dec 15, 2011
103
Oday 20 SF Bay Area/Monterey Bay
Les, I am totally confused now. The OP stated he has the 62nd edition. You answered regarding 1917:confused:

How much do these books really change other then references to latest technologies (radar|GPS)? Do you keep current on the latest book revisions? Do you even open the book or is it being used as a Salon table decoration?

I've been sailing for many years and have the 62nd edition. The 66th has been out for a while and wondering what the delta is between the two.

Thoughts?:confused:


I have a 56th edition on the shelf I bought new for $23. I picked up the latest edition at Barnes and Noble yesterday and choked when I saw the $78 price tag.:eek: I'd like to know how much these change edition to edition myself before I lay down that kinda money on a book.
 

Joe

.
Jun 1, 2004
8,161
Catalina 27 Mission Bay, San Diego
other than the big change over from Loran to GPS So if your edition is published after 2000 or so... I can't imagine a lot of significant changes. So rather than updating a ten or twelve year old book, I'd spend the money on a subscription to Sail or Cruising world to keep up on the new developments.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.