Chainplate Fix Hunter 410

dLj

.
Mar 23, 2017
5,268
Belliure 41 Back in the Chesapeake
Hi, everyone
Unfortunately, no word from Marlow or anyone else—radio silence, no additional information :(.
I still have a glimmer of hope, though, during my research, I may have identified a 410 with long chain plates in France, about a two-hour drive from my home.
I’m going to try to make it there this week to take as many photos and measurements as possible and, if possible, check out the anchor points and interior backing plates.
If everything works out as I hope, I’ll share everything on the forum.
In the meantime, here are a few photos of my (short) chain plates.
That's a bit sad there's no response...But good news on the boat find!

I see you have welds in your chain plates, something that I strongly feel to be problematic. The room for error is very high and there is no current welding standard that specifies how to weld them. Unless you have either a knowledgeable engineer, architect or very good welder it is much better to stay away from welds in chain plates. To successfully achieve a weld quality I would consider appropriate for chain plates; they need to be X-rayed, full penetration, and fully finished on the outer surface. They should be of a weld quality such as a Class A weld per AWS D17.1, with a surface finish requirement that leaves the surface such you can't even see where the weld is....

I look forward to see what you find on that other boat.

dj
 
Jan 11, 2014
14,288
Sabre 362 113 Fair Haven, NY
The important part is not above deck, it is how the chain plate is attached to the hull or structure below deck. For example, this is a photo of what my chainplates look like from the deck:

1794972400488.png


And this is what it looks like below:

1794972438060.png


What I don't have a photo of is the 10 ⅝" bolts that secure the chainplate to the boat's structure.
 

dLj

.
Mar 23, 2017
5,268
Belliure 41 Back in the Chesapeake
The important part is not above deck, it is how the chain plate is attached to the hull or structure below deck. For example, this is a photo of what my chainplates look like from the deck:

View attachment 240564

And this is what it looks like below:

View attachment 240565

What I don't have a photo of is the 10 ⅝" bolts that secure the chainplate to the boat's structure.
With all due respect - it matters both above and below decks how chain plates are manufactured.

Is this a weld seam in your chain plates?

dlochners weld.jpg

What's it's purpose? Is it sealing that deck plate to the actual chain plate? Is that a fillet weld? If a weld is done well, great - they work well. But if they are not done well they can be a source of all sorts of problems leading to chain plate fracture.

Currently there is no welding standard that is specific to welding chain plates for the marine environment - at least none I know of. If you disagree - be specific with your response. Not trying to be confrontational - but I have examined chain plate failures that were caused by poorly executed welds that resulted in masts coming down. I consider it to be a poorly understood issue in the recreational marine market.

dj
 
  • Like
Likes: LLoyd B
Jan 4, 2006
7,868
Hunter 310 West Vancouver, B.C.
I never ceased to be amazed that my boat (and every other Hunter) is not missing a massive chunk(s) out of the side where the outboard plates are attached to the deck only.

1794973947305.png

Mine is exactly the same as yours and again, knocking on whatever I can find, there is not a trace of a crack in the metal. I would also mention that the inboard chainplates are just bolted to the underside of the cabin roof. Again not a trace of a problem. I just pray the hull/cabin seam never lets go.

I look forward to seeing pictures of the long chain plates which your distant neighbour has.

If you are not too confident in having new plates made up in your neighbourhood (unknown materials ? ? and other problems) it may be worth your while to make up drawings of the exact shape of the plates and then have them fabricated in a recognized marine shop that you can trust, wherever in European or the US. The parts are small so I don't think the shipping will kill you Hopefully your neighbour can provide some help with a source.

As far as redesign goes, if it were just me and the Golden Retriever I'd go with a something like a 25% increase in thickness. the rest of the shape is pretty basic. Keep the holes well separated and away from the outside edges below the deck.

I see you have welds in your chain plates, something that I strongly feel to be problematic.
I'm hoping that Hunter had some good procedures for a full penetration weld on these but it's hard to tell. Again no trouble signs.

1794974937566.png
 

dLj

.
Mar 23, 2017
5,268
Belliure 41 Back in the Chesapeake
I never ceased to be amazed that my boat (and every other Hunter) is not missing a massive chunk(s) out of the side where the outboard plates are attached to the deck only.
Well, not every Hunter - the Hunter I used to own had longer chain plates bolted to structural members.

If you are not too confident in having new plates made up in your neighbourhood (unknown materials ? ? and other problems) it may be worth your while to make up drawings of the exact shape of the plates and then have them fabricated in a recognized marine shop that you can trust, wherever in European or the US. The parts are small so I don't think the shipping will kill you Hopefully your neighbour can provide some help with a source.

As far as redesign goes, if it were just me and the Golden Retriever I'd go with a something like a 25% increase in thickness. the rest of the shape is pretty basic. Keep the holes well separated and away from the outside edges below the deck.
Ralph, the region the OP has his boat in France has some superb marine facilities and marine technicians. The French metallurgy industry is one of the best in the world.

I'm hoping that Hunter had some good procedures for a full penetration weld on these but it's hard to tell. Again no trouble signs.

Hard to know what they had for procedures in place. But I bet they had darned good welders doing the work. If you've had no issues to date and there are no signs of that changing, your chain plates are likely just fine.

It's not a question of a single weld but rather the field of welds used in chain plates. It only takes one bad weld in the ones done that can cause the damage. Say you have a hypothetical 100 boats each with 4 welded chain plates making a total of 400 chain plate welds. One bad weld can mean one boat could loose it's mast. While that is only a 0.25% failure rate of welds, but it's a 1% failure rate looking at the number of boats.

The most commonly cited weld procedure for use in boats is AWS D1.6 which is a Structural Welding Code for welding stainless steels. While there are some things about that code that are good, for use in the marine environment it is rather lacking. The only standard I'm aware of that is pretty good is the ABS (American Bureau of Shipping) standard "Requirements for Materials and Welding for Stainless Steels". However, I've never seen that standard applied to sailboats in the recreational marine environment. At least I've never seen any indications of that. Neither have I ever had a conversation where it was stated in the recreational market that it was referenced. It is used in large commercial ship building and repair.

For the OP who is looking to rebuild his chain plates there are the major buckets: material selection, design, fabrication, finish and installation. Each of those steps are important to a successful outcome....

dj
 
Jan 11, 2014
14,288
Sabre 362 113 Fair Haven, NY
Is this a weld seam in your chain plates?

dlochners weld.jpg

What's it's purpose? Is it sealing that deck plate to the actual chain plate? Is that a fillet weld? If a weld is done well, great - they work well. But if they are not done well they can be a source of all sorts of problems leading to chain plate fracture.
The plate serves 2 purposes, one to seal the hole and two it is part of the attachment system. The deck and headliner are solid glass where the chainplate passes through. The plate is through bolted to a 5/16" plate. The chainplate continues down to the structure of the interior where it is attached to a ½" plywood panel running longitudinally which is backed by a ½" fiberglass knee and wall. The top 2 bolts on the chainplate attach to a SS bracket which is bolted to another longitudinal panel. In all there are 10 ⅝" SS through bolts securing the chainplate.

I'll try to remember to get a photo this afternoon of the visible portions.
 

dLj

.
Mar 23, 2017
5,268
Belliure 41 Back in the Chesapeake
The plate serves 2 purposes, one to seal the hole and two it is part of the attachment system. The deck and headliner are solid glass where the chainplate passes through. The plate is through bolted to a 5/16" plate. The chainplate continues down to the structure of the interior where it is attached to a ½" plywood panel running longitudinally which is backed by a ½" fiberglass knee and wall. The top 2 bolts on the chainplate attach to a SS bracket which is bolted to another longitudinal panel. In all there are 10 ⅝" SS through bolts securing the chainplate.

I'll try to remember to get a photo this afternoon of the visible portions.
Let me see if I'm understanding - is this 2nd photo showing the underside of that plate that is sitting on the deck?


dlochners weld2.jpg

dj
 

dLj

.
Mar 23, 2017
5,268
Belliure 41 Back in the Chesapeake
There are two Dave's on this - the owner of this chain plate and me asking questions.

I don't know how Dave's (the other Dave) chain plates were manufactured. I'm trying to wrap my head around the photos he posted. But if I'm guessing right as to what I'm seeing in his photos and that in fact this plate is the same plate that is seen on the top of the deck - the area you are pointing out looks like it very well could be where that top section goes through that rectangular plate and would likely be the bottom of the weld done to secure that top section of the chain plate.

It would be useful to know how thick that top rectangular plate is, 1/4"? 5/16"? 3/8"? Other?

It appears that his chain plates are made in three pieces; the top section where the rigging connects, the rectangular plate it's welded to, and then a bottom section also welded (at an angle) to that rectangular plate that then gets bolted to the boat structure.

If that is correct, then there are two structurally significant welds on each of his chain plates manufactured in this manner. I would guess that this would only be his side stays with his bow and stern connections a different design.

dj
 
Jan 11, 2014
14,288
Sabre 362 113 Fair Haven, NY
What's it's purpose? Is it sealing that deck plate to the actual chain plate? Is that a fillet weld?
Let me see if I'm understanding - is this 2nd photo showing the underside of that plate that is sitting on the deck?
I think the plate serves 2 purposes, sealing the deck plate to the chainplate and as part of the anchoring system for the chainplate. The chainplate itself is one continuous bar. As I mentioned earlier the space around the chainplate hole is solid fiberglass connecting the headliner to the deck. The deck plate is bolted to a matching 5/16" plate under the headliner (yes, I need to finish cleaning up the caulk).

1795035255158.jpeg


@Ralph Johnstone here's a photo of those gray streaks. Not sure why the divots are there and I don't think they are due to corrosion. The divots are aligned and it looks like these might have been intended for the lower plates, but the machinist changed his mind. The scratches on the bend were a result of trying to remove the chainplate. The tolerances were close and with the 2 bends in the plate and an ungodly amount of caulk, it did not slide out easily.



IMG_2909.jpeg



Here's the inside of one of the bends, there are no machining marks. Just a few scratches from removing the chainplate. Note the marks continue from the other side. These are about where the slot for the lower plate would be located.

IMG_2910.jpeg


Finally, here's the lower section of the chainplate. The missing bolt had messed up threads, I keep forgetting to bring the replacement to the boat. We do get some condensation on the chainplate which accounts for some of the darkening around the bolts. All of the bolts have been removed and there is no damage to the plywood beyond the veneer. All of the holes have been saturated with penetrating epoxy to reduce the chances of any future damage.

IMG_3343.jpeg


I am confident in the chainplates ability to hold the mast up. The metal is beefy at 5/16" and there are only superficial scratches with a known origin. The rigger and surveyor who have examined them over the past couple of years were also confident.
 

dLj

.
Mar 23, 2017
5,268
Belliure 41 Back in the Chesapeake
@dlochner OK - I am not understanding how your chain plates are designed and built. Let me show you where my confusion lies.

First you have this image from the deck of the boat:

dlochners weld.jpg

This places that rectangular plate on the deck.

Then you have this photo:

dlochners weld5.jpg

That now places that rectangular plate on the inside of the boat.

How do these two photos work together?

This photo seems to show only one rectangular plate - I'm not understanding how these all go together.

dlochners weld6.jpg

In this last photo, that plate is showing two welds - one for the connection section on the top and one for the chain plate going down into the boat. That rectangular plate has two welds at roughly 45 degrees from each other.

Well, as I'm writing this and reviewing the photos - I think I got it. That second photo above on the interior of the boat shows a plate that is NOT welded to your chain plate structure - it can slide down and off the chain plate as you pull the chain plate out as you remove it going up and out through the top of your deck. That rectangular plate is then a backing plate to the rectangular plate on your deck. Is this correct?

dj
 
Jan 11, 2014
14,288
Sabre 362 113 Fair Haven, NY
Well, as I'm writing this and reviewing the photos - I think I got it. That second photo above on the interior of the boat shows a plate that is NOT welded to your chain plate structure - it can slide down and off the chain plate as you pull the chain plate out as you remove it going up and out through the top of your deck. That rectangular plate is then a backing plate to the rectangular plate on your deck. Is this correct?
Yes, it is the baking plate for the deck plate. When the chainplate is removed it can get jammed in the process and that is one of the causes for the scratches on the chainplate.

Looking at the photos again, the chainplate may not be one continuous bar. The marks @Ralph Johnstone noticed in #28 is the upper part of the chain plate where the shrouds attach. That part is welded into a slot in the deck plate and then ground smooth.
 

dLj

.
Mar 23, 2017
5,268
Belliure 41 Back in the Chesapeake
Sometimes it takes a second or third look to see things clearly.
Hahaha - pretty quick - must have taken me a dozen looks to finally figure out what all your photos were showing...

dj