Also depends on where the OB is mounted, but given that it's on a V25, it's off-center. That means it came come out of the water when the boat lists. That was a problem for me with my Aquarius 7.0 (an A23 with a transom mounted rudder and off-center OB mount), with the prop coming out of the water when it got rough.
If it were me, the cavitation plate would be as deep as I could put it while still being able to tilt the engine to get the whole lower unit out of the water at the dock. That usually means the extra-long shaft version unless you don't mind reaching over the transom to control the OB. The prop being too deep may not be the most efficient, but it's a displacement hull and won't be going fast anyway.
Which doesn't answer your question (which someone already did anyway), but it gives my philosophy on using small outboards on small boats.
