Depends on $$$ available
We have done Moorings and others in the BVI. Moorings is the class of them all - newer boats, great checkout and location, cell phones on all boats, remote base on Virgin Gorda, nice facilities.However, if you are looking for savings as one couple, Sunsail is definitely a savings as noted in the previous post. The boat might be a little older and the facility not as neat, but you will get along fine.We have had a little trouble with all the boats we chartered and it did not matter where we chartered - refrig compressor belt kept falling off, shift mechanism quit, anchor windlass dropped all the chain off at wrong time. But we all have those troubles with our own boats and we fix it and keep on going.If you already own a 32-34' boat, maybe go for a 38'. It is not that much harder to handle. Maybe it will give you ideas for your next boat.Go cheaper and have a great trip.