20 year old and still afloat.
You do not explain what reasons did the surveyor give for declaring that the small rule which came as factory equipment was inadequate. What kind of emergency situation did he have in mind and how many GPH did he suggest as adequate? I hate to tell you, but you can triple the GPH to 1500 and still not be able to handle a serious water intrusion. Rather than size I would give my consideration to the soundness of the circuitry, float switch, plumbing, battery charge and a clean bilge. A second pump to act as back up would be a good idea. Cherubini H27's as you well know have a very shallow bilge and you cannot fit a decent float switch in there. When I bought my boat the pump just had a manual switch. In order to sleep better at night I installed an automatic Rule 500GPH. It is electronic and it turns itself on every 2 1/2 minutes. If the impeller detects water resistance it keeps on pumping, if not it shuts itself off. The switch now alaways remains on. The drainage on the batteries is minimal but they are constantly being replenished by an on-board battery charger. I think the surveyor has missed the mark and the insurance company is a little overzealous in conducting a survey on a small boat.