Atomic 4 Engine

Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Joe

I have a frozen atomic 4 engine on a C30. Debating whether to rebuilt the engine or to buy a outboard. Rebuilt engine to cost ~$6,000. Worried that a outboard would not perform as good as inboard. Any suggestions? If outboard would be OK, what size outboard would be needed?
 
P

Peter Hine

$6,000 - WHEW!

Six grand to rebuilt an A-4 sounds pretty high. I friend of mine just replaced the anemic 11-HP Universal diesel in his C30 with a brand new 25HP Universal, at a cost of about $5,500 for the motor, plus installation of about $1,000. If you want to replace with an OB, you'll need a pretty big one to push the 10,000 pound C-30 at any speed with a reserve. I've got a C-27 with a 2000 15HP Johnson 2-stroke in the well, which replaced a similar 9.9. Both motors are fine in my boat, which is about 6,000 lb. The 15 has more reserve horsepower when punching into seas or headwind, or pulling the dink. It comes at higher fuel usage, about 1.25GPH at 2/3 throttle, which is about 5.2 knots on my 27. I would think you'd want at least 15HP, maybe 20. As I recall the A-4 has about 30, which is about right for the C-30. You'd also have the hassle of a transom bracket, and the resale value of a C-30 with an OB would be quite low, I would think. If it were me, I'd look for a lower cost rebuild, or consider a new diesel. Try Moyer Marine (they're somewhere in Pennsylvania-check the web for them, or Good Old Boat Magazine.). A-4s are all they do. Parts, advice, and rebuilts. Good luck
 
B

Bob Sawyer

My story & advice

When I bought my 1974 C27 via auction at the end of the season, it too had a sciezed A4 engine (it hadn't run in 3 years). I received a quote to rebuild the engine to original specs of $3200. I thought that was too high. I asked my auto mechanic what he coud do. He had worked on A4's before and informed me that they were a simple, reliable, engine and probably didn't need a complete overhaul. We pulled it out and he got it going one winter's afternoon. We replaced some of the perifials and put it back in. It's been running perfectly for 5 years now. Cost $1500 - $2000. My previous sailboat had an outboard - I prefer my inboard A4. I wouldn't give up on it without first trying to get it going and doing standard maintenance on it. Good luck!
 
M

Moebetta

Good old A-4

I have a 74 Catalina 27 last month I pulled my A-4 out the have it rebuilt at the shop 1200.00.It can be done cheeper. The A-4 is easy to work on and the A-4 is a good engine. Pull it out and have a look. I hope to put it back in this week going to insall new prop.You can contact me at web site below. Joe JL Shipyard
 
Status
Not open for further replies.