Americas Cup. Is this "Sailing"?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Feb 26, 2004
22,986
Catalina 34 224 Maple Bay, BC, Canada
Seems like they could do a DVR style pause for commercial then resume. Somehow I think they either believe that the public DEMANDS that things be live to the second, or if there was a delay they couldn't legally call it live coverage anymore. In either case I think they are doing it in the name of the viewer, while giving the viewer a lesser product as a result.
What a good way to express the possibilities. Thanks.
 

Gunni

.
Mar 16, 2010
5,937
Beneteau 411 Oceanis Annapolis
This AC is like deja vu all over. We saw the same thing in 1988 when Conner took on the Kiwis with a 90 foot cat and retained the Cup with a new Stars and Stripes that introduced the world to a fast cat with a wing sail. That race also boosted a young designer Gino Morelli to stardom and opportunity. Know that name? Morelli went on to design a bunch of great cruising cats under the Leopard brand. The AC has a tradition of advancing the joy of sailing. Time marches on fellas. G.
 
Jan 4, 2009
15
Pacific Dolphin 24 Phoenix, Arizona
I flew over from Arizona just to see the first 6 races. Sat at Crissy Field yesterday. The start was straight out from us and we had a great view as they came right at us then rounded the first mark right in front of us maybe 300 yards off shore. Then got to see the rounding of the third mark and the start of the horse race to the finish. It may not be traditional, and is nothing like sailing on my Dolphin 24, but you can't deny that it is certainly exciting to watch!
 
Jan 6, 2010
1,520
I posted earlier in this thread, but left out some additional disappointing thoughts.

The previous Cup races on monohulls had a trickle down effect from new materials, hardware, electronics, sails, spars etc. for the sailboat community.
Advances would show up in the manufacturer's boatbuilding.

However, with the cats, I haven't seen much in these boats that will show up on production or the boat builders' drawing board. like seeing a docked boat with a wing sail standing tall.

CR
 
Mar 26, 2011
3,677
Corsair F-24 MK I Deale, MD
Multihull racers learn to control heel very precisely for the reasons you have outlined; without tight control the windward hull goes up and down, which is slow.

The answer? Not the foils; the windward foil is retracted and there is no "vector" from the leeward foil that would make a difference. Ballast? Not moveable like beach cats, so no. Sail trim? Yes, very quick. But the main factor is steering for constant angle of heel (same this the AC 40s--no foils). At greater speeds, cats can be steered for constant angle of heel with very small but quick corrections. But you've got to be attentive. I've flown a hull just out for miles and these guys actually have skill.

----

All this talk of "not sailing".... I wonder if part of it is that some monohull cruisers don't understand the subtleties of performance (not cruising) multihulls and for that reason can understand or enjoy the differences in tactics? True, tacking duels are out (I always found those as exciting as watching paint dry) and the fine points of boat speed are in (there are much greater differences between 2 cats moving through waves than design, much greater differences between 2 crews and helmsman than on monohulls).

Sure, one-design racing can help make things closer--yet not always--but that isn't what the AC was from the start and isn't what it is now. It's an arms race.
1
 

Gunni

.
Mar 16, 2010
5,937
Beneteau 411 Oceanis Annapolis
Here is a shot of the 1988 Stars & Stripes, notice the similarities with the current boats. 25 years ago!



And here is a shot of what the Kiwis showed up with:


I hope the Americas Cup stays in California. The Golden State guys know how to make sail racing interesting for spectators. Must be that hollywood energy!
 
Dec 26, 2012
359
MacGregor 25 San Diego
I think we'll all be surprised how much does trickle down. I dont see wings becoming commonplace in the marinas but there is a lot more to these boats than just the wing. The hydraulic systems are one thing that is really interesting me. Human powered hydraulic pumps that can run anything from winches to raising and lowering the boards, to changing the wing shape, to...... The possibilities are endless, and it really changes how you can package things. You're not limited by where the ropes can run without snagging.

That's just one of the technologies here. I'm betting a lot more than that trickles down, at least to smaller cheaper racing boats.
 

jviss

.
Feb 5, 2004
7,089
Tartan 3800 20 Westport, MA
I think we'll all be surprised how much does trickle down. I dont see wings becoming commonplace in the marinas but there is a lot more to these boats than just the wing. The hydraulic systems are one thing that is really interesting me. Human powered hydraulic pumps that can run anything from winches to raising and lowering the boards, to changing the wing shape, to...... The possibilities are endless, and it really changes how you can package things. You're not limited by where the ropes can run without snagging.

That's just one of the technologies here. I'm betting a lot more than that trickles down, at least to smaller cheaper racing boats.
I am hoping the wings will inspire sailmakers, and result in some newer, fresher cruising technology: maybe in the form of new control methods. May be a two-section, collapsible main "wing?"

By the way, "human powered hydraulic pumps" on boats: backstay adjusters, these have been around seemingly forever. Interesting topic, though. Maybe we could see a hydraulic accumulator that provides the muscle for an autopilot drive that is charged up by the engine, and lasts long enough for a 4 to 6 hour sailing passage - that would be cool!
 

Gunni

.
Mar 16, 2010
5,937
Beneteau 411 Oceanis Annapolis
At the end of one of the LV races a few weeks ago, the Kiwis sailed up to the spectator grandstands while they awaited the call on wind conditions for race 2. they did not drop an anchor, or catch a mooring. They simply stalled their wing very precisely to hold position, drifting back and forward a few feet. It was amazing to see.

That said, I would rather be able to drop my sails, especially in a slip.
 
Dec 26, 2012
359
MacGregor 25 San Diego
Yeah, unless the wing can pivot a full 360 degrees having one on a boat in a slip could be dangerous since a wind shift could power up the boat. In one of the video segments they were talking about the process of launching these boats and one of the oracle guys said something to the effect of "usually it behaves quite well at the dock, but if the wind picks up we have a mooring near the dock"
 

Kermit

.
Jul 31, 2010
5,669
AquaCat 12.5 17342 Wateree Lake, SC
A catamaran sailor sailed briefly on our H23 a couple of months ago. I asked how she liked sailing on a monohull. Her reply was, "It's great if you like sleeping."

Catamaran sailors apparently don't see our type of sailing as "sailing" any more than some of us see high-tech sailing as "sailing." I personally think it's cool as all getout. As my daddy used to say, every dog to his own bone.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.