As for your reason for keeping a worn out joker valve..
Jabsco no longer makes the proprietary joker valve that fits our toilet. Even the smallest do not fit. No worries, as the toilet works just fine.
so what's preventing you from replacing the pump
The macerator motor assembly (not really a pump) works just fine, so no need to replace. And no leaks.
However, the inside of the pump cylinder also wears, preventing even new seals, o-rings from performing efficiently even if you can still get them.
Our toilet electric macerator has no cylinders. The motor shaft and fixed metal assembly works much like a blender that also brings in sea water as it spits bowl contents out the discharge hose. Pretty simple and effective.
You can even use the dry mode, followed by enough water to rinse behind the flush.
These Jabsco electric toilets have no dry mode. Either the sea water valve is open or closed. In order to achieve a dry toilet I have to close the valve and then run the flush motor until dry. Normally, that is what I do after each cruise where I flush two gallons of fresh water to clear the hose of any remaining material. The aft discharge hose does not gravity feed all the way to the tank. There is a hose low point to the stringer that encloses the tank. The hose then rises about ten inches to cross through the stringer and into the tank. That is where the clog was that I covered in a previous thread. My thought was that the PO, over time, did not clear the hose with fresh water, which caused the clog to form in the first place.
Whoever designed the toilets for our boat was a genius. Using a proprietary joker valve was not the best idea, but in the scope of the macerator operation, it is simple, effective and no parts to wear out, other than the motor itself. The old joker valve seems to have not effect on toilet operation.