For my Catalina 34 I went with UK Halsey and had excellent results.
When we bought our 2008 Hunter 38 it came with UK Halsey too. Happy with them too.
One thing I did learn through my experience and watching the folks in next slip is work with someone who is local. I dealt with a UK Halsey rep who has boat in our marina. He took care of all measurements, picked up the old sails to use as guides, returned old and new right to the boat, installed new and checked for fit and all in all made my life very easy.
Guy next door went with a mail order deal who used a loft in China to save a few bucks. OK maybe more than a few because it is a 44 foot boat. No help, no support, head sail came with wrong color sunbrella and was too big. Main was cut too long as well. Had to send the whole mess back to China to be recut and redone. And he had no local support. All in all I don't think he actually saved any money when it was all done, and that was before the lost sailing days and the aggregation toll.