Al - i just spent most of the late summer and early fall replacing both bulkheads on my 81 Catalina 27. I purchased marine grade plywood from a place here locally that was recommended to me by others. Boulter is certainly and option, I have used them before as well, but shipping costs are not cheap. If you can find marine grade(and I would not recommend anything but) from a local place, or even a good lumberyard that is near you may be able to order it for you. There is also a product called Okume marine grade, which is similar to teak, but less expensive. I have used that product as well, using a Red Oak stain, and Cetol Marine, and I cannot tell the difference between that and my original teak. I have some pictures if you want me to send some to you. I followed the same path you are thinking, carefully remove the existing ones so that you have something for a template. I actually bought a cheap piece of 1/2" plywood, traced the old ones onto the plywood, dry fit them, and made some minor adjustments, and when that was done, I simply clamped them to the top of the marine plywood, and using a router and a really good top-collar straight cutter, cut the new one. They fit better than the old ones did, and if I ever need to replace them, I have the templates already.
I coated all edges in glass, then 3 coats of cetol marine, and 3 coats of gloss. Feel free to email directly and I will be glad to answer any additional questions.