Yes, If you ever use the boom to hoist something- say picking up a man overboard or a dingy. You'd want the end-of-boom to be counter-supported to handle the weight.Question: Is there any need/value to keeping the topping lift in place but slack?
Only if you are a 'Belt and Suspenders' type of person.Question: Is there any need/value to keeping the topping lift in place but slack?
No...... that's the reason you're installing a rigid vang... so you don't have to mess with the topping lift. With the trend towards larger roach mainsails, the topping lift becomes an inconvenience because it often hangs up the battens when changing tacks. I wrapped it around the forestay to get it out of the way. It's there still, but I haven't used it in the 9 years since the new vang was installed. If it's rigged that way, I suppose you could use it for a backup halyard, but mine wasn't.(The adjustment was on the boom end.)Question: Is there any need/value to keeping the topping lift in place but slack?
The solid vang was OEM on my B323. Coupled with the stack pack, I was not content with the range of vertical boom travel, which limited sail trim. I could have lived with that as most people do, but.... Also in it's lowest rest position it hit the bimini that I made.... Also I had a problem with rain getting into the stack pack and gathering in the sail folds- until I raised sail. With the solid vang removed, back at the slip I could dip the end of the boom so the rain water ran off the lowered end.... With a shackle on the mast end of the new vang, it is easy to move the vang/shackle out to the toe rail for a preventer of sorts.... And I guess I could move this vang to put the dingy on the cabin top when anchored or in slip. Keeps the foredeck cleared.... Along with the vang conversion, I re-did the stackpack's lazy jack lines so I can adjust them from the cockpit.... I guess that's all.Ron, may I ask why you went from a fixed vang back to topping lift?
That's just not true, many, many big boats use rigid vangs.... If you want to support the boom for lifting, use the main halyard. The vang connects to the boom bracket with a clevis pin and is very simple to release so you can do what you want with the boom. Keep the old soft vang to use as a preventor or MOB tackle.Thanks Ron. Makes sense. Especially of interest because Im getting a bimini for the HaHa this Fall. Besides, looks like rigid vangs are mostly for smaller boats.
Looked at your pix and went to the Garhauer site. Thanks for the tip.
More importantly, thanks for letting me know I was starting to sound like a liberal, opining on things I clearly knew little about...