Are you wondering, should I get a furling Mainsail?

jssailem

SBO Weather and Forecasting Forum Jim & John
Oct 22, 2014
24,938
CAL 35 Cruiser #21 moored EVERETT WA
We get questions every year about furling mainsails.
  • How do I fix my stuck furling Mainsail?
  • Why is my mainsail not furling?
  • Should I order a furling mainsail?
and many other nuanced queries. Quantum Sails just posted an FAQ on Furling Mainsails that may provide answers for you.

When asked, "Should I get a furling mainsail?" I think this statement may be a helpful answer for which direction to take.
"The decision ultimately comes down to how you sail and whether you value simplicity or performance more."​
​
​
 
May 24, 2004
7,235
CC 30 South Florida
Never had a furling mainsail and no longer have the patience to deal with new and different types of jams.
 
  • Like
Likes: pgandw

dLj

.
Mar 23, 2017
5,273
Belliure 41 Back in the Chesapeake
I have a boom roller furling main sail. It's an old design and no longer made. However, I very much like it and how it works. It does require figuring out how best to run it but once it's all tweeked, it's really functional. I can reef to any size while sailing better than any reefing system I've ever used. I have infinite sail-size options. It can't get stuck as in mast systems sometimes do. If something happens to the furling system, I run the sail as a standard hank-on main works.

I've run some modern boom roller furling systems and do not like them as well as the one I have.

dj
 
Sep 11, 2013
252
Catalina 25 6106 Lake Erie Metro Park
We installed a CDI MR2 main sail furler five years ago and it was the best money I ever spent on our Catalina 25. North Sails sales tech came out and took measurements while the mast was down and made a custom sail.
Is there a performance loss? Yes, but we’re fair weather day sailors and can’t tell the difference anyway. It’s attached behind the mast and while it looks kind of funky, I never have to get up off my butt to raise/lower the main and reefing adjustments are infinite.
Expensive? You bet ($3500, furler + new mainsail) but after I fell from the cabin top into the cabin while attempting to lower the main sail in some choppy water, my wife never even asked how much it cost.
I’m over seventy five now and it has meant that we are able to safely continue sailing.

Tom G
 

capta

.
Jun 4, 2009
5,117
Pearson 530 Admiralty Bay, Bequia SVG
The IMRF main is one of the greatest inventions for sailors, since fiberglass, in my very experienced opinion.
The dammed In Mast Roller Furling systems DO NOT JAM, any more than boats hit reefs or multihulls capsize on their own! PEOPLE cause all three of those problems.
Just like anything, especially on boats, attention must be paid to what one is doing. If one is rolling the sail in or out and it appears to be jamming, then STOP, reverse the sail movement a few inches, trim the sheet or whatever is necessary, then try again.
In ten years of sailing a 53' ketch, a lot more than most people sail their boat (we chartered some of those years), our IMRF main sails NEVER jammed so badly we couldn't undo the problem within minutes. I pluralized mains as we got a new one in that period). It is definitely much more difficult to furl/unfurl a baggy old sail than a proper sail, but with care one can be successful, every time.
Situational awareness is a must at all times on a boat (and in life?) to prevent little problems before they become big ones, and with any RF sail, this is especially true.
However, even on the slightest, most remote chance that one could cause a serious jam situation with an IMRF, I wouldn't give up the infinite reefing that IMRF gives me.
 

capta

.
Jun 4, 2009
5,117
Pearson 530 Admiralty Bay, Bequia SVG
I have a boom roller furling main sail. It's an old design and no longer made. However, I very much like it and how it works. It does require figuring out how best to run it but once it's all tweeked, it's really functional. I can reef to any size while sailing better than any reefing system I've ever used. I have infinite sail-size options. It can't get stuck as in mast systems sometimes do. If something happens to the furling system, I run the sail as a standard hank-on main works.

I've run some modern boom roller furling systems and do not like them as well as the one I have.

dj
I sailed with one of those systems from Pago Pago to St. Thomas via the Indian Ocean and the Med, and as dLj said they worked great. The newer systems do produce a better sail shape, but beating in 40 knots for 10 days, or running in a hurricane (we didn't know it was a hurricane, as it was before satellite weather), does sail shape matter all that much?
What made it especially great was that the mast was in the cockpit, with the helm on the mast.
Were I to design a cruising boat, the in cockpit mast would be right up there in importance, and I would do my best to design it into the boat. I think the OI 41 was a perfect candidate for that, but it probably would have been too radical back then!
 
  • Like
Likes: JamesG161

jssailem

SBO Weather and Forecasting Forum Jim & John
Oct 22, 2014
24,938
CAL 35 Cruiser #21 moored EVERETT WA
I recently read the book. “At the Mercy of the Sea” By JOHN KRETSCHMER.
It is the story of three sailors in a Caribbean Hurricane. ]

There is a serious discussion about the benefits of mainsail reefing during high wind conditions from the cockpit.
 
  • Like
Likes: JamesG161

MFD

.
Jun 23, 2016
305
Hunter 41DS Pacific NW USA
I have one of those Selden in-mast furling systems.

I habe a love/hate relationship with it.

Can we please have people search well known information instead of bringing up the same old stuff?
 
Aug 2, 2010
564
J-Boat J/99 Cobourg
Having had both I will say that if you want easy, the furling main makes a little evening sail the easiest thing you can imagine. If you want fast it is not the answer.

My furling main was old when I bought the boat and had vertical battens so it was a bit finicky but paying attention was all it ever needed.
 

dLj

.
Mar 23, 2017
5,273
Belliure 41 Back in the Chesapeake
I have one of those Selden in-mast furling systems.

I habe a love/hate relationship with it.

Can we please have people search well known information instead of bringing up the same old stuff?
@MFD I'm not sure what you are looking for? I don't "bring up the same old stuff" - I give my opinion based on direct experience.

I've only sailed one boat with in mast main sail furling so my experience level on that is low. Hence I did not speak to it. I have spent decades sailing boats with more tradition systems and my current boat has in boom roller furling. I've also sailed other more modern in boom roller furling systems - hence my comment on those systems.

dj
 
  • Like
Likes: MFD

MFD

.
Jun 23, 2016
305
Hunter 41DS Pacific NW USA
Fair enough, and with a boom roller the sail always comes down when you need it to.

I was caught some years ago when new to my inmast with the wind piping up to ~30kn plus gusts and we had problems.

For sure, inexperience and blame it on the owner/operator or crew. Meanwhile being able to reduce with 100% reliability, always, even under fatigue or other considerations, is an important consideration to me. Especially in coastal or inland waters.
 

MFD

.
Jun 23, 2016
305
Hunter 41DS Pacific NW USA
There is a serious discussion about the benefits of mainsail reefing during high wind conditions from the cockpit.
One thing I do like I do like about my inmast system is exactly that. Being able to easily have a sliver of main out, no need to go on deck or special work for reefing. Definitely a good thing. It is just more maintenance and a touch more knowledge as opposed to ‘the sail comes down and gravity is your friend’. ?
 
Nov 21, 2026
2
Morgan Out Island 41 Ketch Baltimore
Good thread to keep pinned. One option that doesn't come up much here: a behind-the-mast furler that rolls the main up on its own stay just aft of the mast, like a headsail furler moved back. No mast modification and no in-boom gear, and if the furler ever jams you can still lower the sail on its halyard.
The tradeoffs are worth knowing before you spend money: you give up battens and some roach, so you lose a bit of sail area and upwind punch. Sail shape when partly reefed is not as good as slab reefing. In exchange, reefing from the cockpit in any wind is a big safety gain for single-handers and older crews.
Disclosure: I make 3DFurler, which builds behind-the-mast main and mizzen furlers along with headsail units, so I'm biased. Happy to answer questions on how they're set up.
 

colemj

.
Jul 13, 2004
1,180
Dolphin Catamaran Dolphin 460 Mystic, CT
Good thread to keep pinned. One option that doesn't come up much here: a behind-the-mast furler that rolls the main up on its own stay just aft of the mast, like a headsail furler moved back. No mast modification and no in-boom gear, and if the furler ever jams you can still lower the sail on its halyard.
The tradeoffs are worth knowing before you spend money: you give up battens and some roach, so you lose a bit of sail area and upwind punch. Sail shape when partly reefed is not as good as slab reefing. In exchange, reefing from the cockpit in any wind is a big safety gain for single-handers and older crews.
Disclosure: I make 3DFurler, which builds behind-the-mast main and mizzen furlers along with headsail units, so I'm biased. Happy to answer questions on how they're set up.
Are you what used to be Alado furlers from Brazil? Alado website now points to yours when ordering.

I used to have an Alado and thought it was a great furler for the price point. The design animations on your website show that the furler design has changed a lot since the original Alado. Price is also more.

Are they 3D printed now, or is that term just a marketing thing?

Mark
 

capta

.
Jun 4, 2009
5,117
Pearson 530 Admiralty Bay, Bequia SVG
One thing I do like I do like about my inmast system is exactly that. Being able to easily have a sliver of main out, no need to go on deck or special work for reefing. Definitely a good thing. It is just more maintenance and a touch more knowledge as opposed to ‘the sail comes down and gravity is your friend’. ?
I call In Mast Roller Furling infinite reefing. I absolutely loved it!
 
Apr 8, 2010
2,259
Ericson Yachts Olson 34 28400 Portland OR
Having had both I will say that if you want easy, the furling main makes a little evening sail the easiest thing you can imagine. If you want fast it is not the answer.
IMHO, this short statement is precisely where "the duck comes down" ....!
:)

The last several seasons a small group of friends have been taking turns doing late afternoon/evening sails on east other's boats. One boat has factory in-mast furling. We ALL love the ease of putting that boat to bed after a couple of hours of fun sailing, as the sun sets.

We all, including the owner of the boat with the furling, dislike the inefficiency of the mainsail with the reduced area and the cut that it requires to furl -- this is a new main, BTW. Shaping it very much is difficult and getting it close to correct when evaluating the 'slot' for going to weather is less than desirable, to put it mildly.

Huge compromise, but we have all owned high-performing sailboats for decades and nowadays have decided to enjoy (often just one) microbrew and some chips, and just like being out on the water under sail! :)
The difference really snaps into focus when we come back in with my Olson. I DO have lazy jacks and a split sail cover, so putting it away is not near the former hassle of corralling a lowered flapping sail, flaking/tying it down, and manipulating the standard sail cover into place.

I wish there was a furling main sail scheme - Affordable! - that retained shaping and area. :waycool:
 
Jan 1, 2006
8,187
Slickcraft 26 Sailfish
What would a discussion be without some dissent?
I had a Selden IMFS on my H356 and didn't like it at all. I've posted before about the jams, the full length round vertical battens penetrating the bottom of the batten pocket, and the exploded block that would have killed someone if it hit them on the head. For this thread I'd like address the infinite reefing. I've learned over the years that my sail was too deep - either by stretching or by design. In any event that would cause the uneven rolling that led to jams. Since the sail was deep, when rolled the chord depth increased. The first reef line was OK but further than that the sail would be so deep that it produced drag and heel that made reefing any more moot. So in effect for my system I could only use up to the first reef.