Fresh water "Pressure Capacity Tank" - Keep or Toss ?

Dec 1, 2020
135
CAL 27 Illahee / Brownsville WA
If the tank is in a vertical orientation, and the inlet is at the bottom, and the water system is empty (full of air) and you start the pump, the air is going to be compressed as the water attempts to fill the tank. This is what is being described, like a plastic water bottle held underwater, or even a glass and you sink shows the same effect.

I was not aware that the trapped air would eventually be absorbed by the water surface inside the tank.

Now that I know more about this, adding a Shrader valve to my 3" PVC "tank" and making sure it was mounted vertically might be retrofitted again to allow the faucet to feed water without cycling the pump.

Research it. Google is your friend.
 
Oct 26, 2008
6,280
Catalina 320 Barnegat, NJ
Now that I know more about this, adding a Shrader valve to my 3" PVC "tank" and making sure it was mounted vertically might be retrofitted again to allow the faucet to feed water without cycling the pump.
What do you mean by "cycling"? Is it repetitively turning on and off while you run water at the faucet? Or is it just turning on and running while you have the water running?
 
Dec 1, 2020
135
CAL 27 Illahee / Brownsville WA
Sorry. Poor wording. Pump running when faucet opens nearly immediately.

I will say the variable speed pump is amazingly quiet compared to the old dinosaur removed.

When the old tank was in the system I could draw a few cups worth of water without the pump, turning on, which was nice.
 
Jan 4, 2006
7,268
Hunter 310 West Vancouver, B.C.
I was not aware that the trapped air would eventually be absorbed by the water surface inside the tank.
It may seem odd but in fact it does :

1687459606470.png


I can't be bothered to dig out my old text books on this but there are numerous similar charts to this on the web so this one is likely close :

Normally I don't like posting charts like this when I see a comment such as the one below :

What does it mean that "water will dissolve air?"
When I was teaching, I found that feeding students all the required material discouraged them from being aggressive and doing their own research.
 
Last edited:

jviss

.
Feb 5, 2004
7,089
Tartan 3800 20 Westport, MA
It may seem odd but in fact it does :

View attachment 217154

I can't be bothered to dig out my old text books on this but there are numerous similar charts to this on the web so this one is likely close :

Normally I don't like posting charts like this when I see a comment such as theases one below :



When I was teaching, I found that feeding students all the required material discouraged them from being aggressive and doing their own research.
Thanks Ralph. I'm familiar with the gas laws and gases being absorbed into fluids; I just thought the turn of phrase odd. But, seriously, at 30psig, how long would it take to absorb a significant amount of air into water? I mean, I don't know, but my intuition is that it's not going to happen quickly, or much at all. And, I don't think that's the reason accumulators have bladders, but then, I could be wrong on both of these points.
 
Oct 26, 2008
6,280
Catalina 320 Barnegat, NJ
Well, they also have bladders so that you can control the air pressure more easily. @Radio Flyer was also explaining that in the old days, when accumulator tanks didn't have bladders, you would have to periodically drain the tank (introduce air again and again), to keep the functioning properly. The loss of air was a function of air dissolving in water, assuming there was no other way for the air to escape.

Probably, one of the reasons why the pump turns on almost instantly and doesn't behave the same as the original fixed speed pump is because it is variable speed ... I assume it reacts to lesser pressure. I wouldn't worry one little bit about that aspect of the way it functions.
 
Jan 4, 2006
7,268
Hunter 310 West Vancouver, B.C.
I'm familiar with the gas laws and gases being absorbed into fluids;
Sorry, no gas laws here. No P, no V, and no nRT. Just the solubility of a gas (or gasses) in a liquid. Like the bubbles you see in a freshly drawn glass of water because the pressure has been reduced. Like the bubbles you see in your Champagne (but nothing in Newfoundland Screech) due to the opening of the bottle causing a pressure loss.

And, I don't think that's the reason accumulators have bladders,
If not to prevent the dissolution of air into the water, then what is the purpose of bladder ? Could you possibly be wrong :yikes: ?