Dimmer switch for LED lighting in cabin

Aug 1, 2012
59
Beneteau 40 Rondout Yacht Basin, New York
I have replaced all my cabin overhead halogen bulbs with LED. i would like to replace the standard rocker switches with dimmer switches (there are many available) but would like to know if anyone has done this and what switches will fit in the cut-out where the old ones are. any help appreciated.

Capt. Pete
 
Mar 29, 2011
169
Beneteau 361 Charlotte,Vt
I've been wanting to replace the switches on my 361. I also installed LEDs in all the overhead lights. The are so bright that it's blinding sometimes. So I will be interested if you find a solutions.
 
Nov 6, 2006
10,067
Hunter 34 Mandeville Louisiana
An interesting thread indeed.. Most of the LED's sold for cabin use are not able to be dimmed unless specifically noted in the bulb's data sheet..
 
Aug 1, 2012
59
Beneteau 40 Rondout Yacht Basin, New York
Making assumptions usually gets one in trouble! I ordered my LED replacement bulbs through this website and ASSUME they can be dimmed? Anyone know? Thanks
 

pateco

.
Aug 12, 2014
2,207
Hunter 31 (1983) Pompano Beach FL
An interesting thread indeed.. Most of the LED's sold for cabin use are not able to be dimmed unless specifically noted in the bulb's data sheet..
You cannot just use a standard rheostat to control LEDs. What these dimmers do is provide the correct voltage to power the LED, but in pulses using PWM (Pulse Wave Modulation). The frequency of the pulses determines the light level.


How to Dim an LED Without Compromising Light Quality


I have noticed that at really low light levels, when the pulses slow down, you may see these pulses as a mild flicker depending on your vision sensitivity and the quality of the PWM Module . Sort of how some people see the flicker on CRT TVs, and others don't.
 
Nov 8, 2010
11,386
Beneteau First 36.7 & 260 Minneapolis MN & Bayfield WI
Making assumptions usually gets one in trouble! I ordered my LED replacement bulbs through this website and ASSUME they can be dimmed? Anyone know? Thanks
To be precise, ANY LED component can be dimmed, with the right dimmer control. As Pateco notes, if the dimmer is designed for LEDs and is PWC based, it will be OK. But an old school rheostat dimmer will not, UNLESS the the LED FIXTURE has been designed for that, typically with a OP-AMP built in to supply the correct voltage to the LED component regardless of it dropping on the wire. It also then has to pulse the supply to the LED so it can dim.
 
  • Like
Likes: pateco
Aug 1, 2012
59
Beneteau 40 Rondout Yacht Basin, New York
The 2 in 1LED dimmer mentioned in the above post seems to be the one. Spoke with the tech guy at Armacost this morning and he was able to answer all my questions - nice people BTY if you ever need assistance AND thanks all for your help in this matter.
 
  • Like
Likes: pateco

pateco

.
Aug 12, 2014
2,207
Hunter 31 (1983) Pompano Beach FL
The 2 in 1LED dimmer mentioned in the above post seems to be the one. Spoke with the tech guy at Armacost this morning and he was able to answer all my questions - nice people BTY if you ever need assistance AND thanks all for your help in this matter.
Let us know how it works
 
Jun 6, 2006
6,990
currently boatless wishing Harrington Harbor North, MD
I would beg to disagree. ALL LEDs can be dimmed by reducing the voltage only (you don't need a PWM circuit just a variable resistor aka rheostat). With that said you will note that the current bulb has either a resistor built into it to make it work with a 12 volt system or there is a resister on the board the LED is soldered to. All LEDs operate at 2-3 volts at the bear terminals. It does not matter which type you have as long as you just put the rheostat in SERIES with the power to the bulb/circuit board. Alternately you can play around with fixed resistors switching them in and out and just use a single double position switch (off-low-high). Higher resistance dims the LED more.
For the mathematically inclined non-electrical engineers you need to measure the amps (milliamp range typical) for the bulb. V=IR --> R=V/I, let V= battery voltage and I be the current you measured. R is the LED's resistance overall in ohms. If you double that the bulb will see 1/2 the amps and dim by something like 50%. So if you measured 2 milliamps =0.02 amps your resistance is 13.6/0.02=680 ohms. if you add a 680 ohm resistor (you will not be able to find one that matches exactly BTW as they come in standard "sizes") in series with the bulb it will see 1/2 the amps and dim by approx 50%. If you put a 680/4= 170 the bulb will dime by 25%.....
Radio shack has fixed resistors and the 1 watt version work fine.