Question about through hull fitting

Mar 20, 2012
3,983
Cal 34-III, MacGregor 25 Salem, Oregon
I assume you have your answers now?
no... other than the addition of glass fibers, which i had considered but which for that small hole vs the thickness of the epoxy, is not really an issue.
and any glass fiber reinforcment would have to be done in a taperd depression from the outside of the hull to do any good, otherwise, if it was done only on the inside, which is how most DIYers do it, it can still chunk out if the bond breaks loose from the hole due to poor preparation.

I have used fiberglass and marine tex to make repairs and fill holes on many boats, and depending on the size of the hole/damage and the boat itseld, i choose the method that I think will work the best.... and ive never had a failure.

I have also done like other people have and actually mixed up epoxy, thickened it with fillers and then used it in the same manner with the same results.... marine tex is just handy to use.

taking into consideration the size of the boat, its usage, and where the hole is located, filling a hole on a small boat that isnt taking a lot of stress isnt rocket science nor does it take the most intensive process in the industry.

so no, all things considered in this particular situation, I have not heard a reason not to use marine tex, but only ways to make filling the hole more complicated for the OP...

a lot of people will have an opinion, and some of them dont have anything to back it up with... but they only agree with what they have heard from someone else, who has heard it from someone else... uninformed guesswork... wives tales... rumors.... and misinformation

I have experience to back up my claim here.
 
Feb 6, 1998
11,722
Canadian Sailcraft 36T Casco Bay, ME
a lot of people will have an opinion, and some of them dont have anything to back it up with... but they only agree with what they have heard from someone else...

I have experience to back up my claim here.
Actually you have some luck on your side.. This luck does not equate to experience... No hole below the waterline, any larger than a simple screw hole, and even that is questionable, should ever be filled with just thickened epoxy... :doh:

There were people with trucks on the ice last weekend at Sebago lake 75' from open water with only a 4.5" thickness where their trucks were. They too have experience but no one in their right mind would suggest it is safe doing that....;)
 
Mar 20, 2012
3,983
Cal 34-III, MacGregor 25 Salem, Oregon
Actually you have some luck on your side.. This luck does not equate to experience... No hole below the waterline should ever be filled with just thickened epoxy... :doh:
Well... maybe. all things being equal, I would rather be Lucky, than Good....:D
 
Mar 20, 2012
3,983
Cal 34-III, MacGregor 25 Salem, Oregon
Luck shouldn't be depended upon when it comes to safety.

I thnk you got your answer(s) but apparently you don't like them.
When it comes to safety, a person should do all they can to insure success and hope they are lucky enough to not have anything else go wrong... but one should never rely on luck alone..