The posts offered here had alot of good takes in this thread. So mine is a 2-parter. First is my political take & secondly the question of required training.
First, I did like what Scott had to say on how voters have let Big Brother do what it wants. And we the voter, have no one to blame but us. For those who are party affiliate remember, everyone gets exactly what they want in life. The parties no longer represent the wishes of the people. I for one, rant-n-rave to others about our government's true role which is bowing to big corporate, interest & greed all the while eroding our rights.
Remember way back when, if the gov't. was gonna screw you over, they would hide it from you? Not anymore, because of our apathy, indifference and ignorance (quoted), it's almost 1984. Hello George Orwell & welcome to Fascism.
Back to mandatory boating safety requirements, I feel training is needed for newbies. Insurance companies already offer discounts for courses. But, a true training course must not limited to the classroom but, also must include onwater training and/or testing. Otherwise, it's only another vehicle for the state to generate money. Unfortunately, this type of course will cost us more $$$. It just keeps going up guys.
Sadly, with training or not, you can't legislate or prevent boating stupidity.
CR