Revuild or replace?

Dec 14, 2003
1,433
Hunter 34 Lake of Two Mountains, QC, Can
Other than corrosion what's wrong with it ? The stainless skimmer seems OK (at least on the picture. These units are easily taken apart for thorough cleaning. You might need to replace the gasket on the top cover. Glass bowl should be also easy to clean. Bronze wool or bronze brush should do wonders on the body. I guess I would go that route rather than replace. But then again, I hate replacing something if I can avoid it.
As Stu often says: your boat your choice. good luck
 
Dec 19, 2006
5,832
Hunter 36 Punta Gorda
Ain't broke

If still working just clean it and that is $$$$$$ if had to replace.
 

KD3PC

.
Sep 25, 2008
1,069
boatless rainbow Callao, VA
just clean it up, the sorry replacement device you will spend $$$ on is junk from the get go.

this is one of the best
 
Jun 5, 2010
1,123
Hunter 25 Burlington NJ
As long as you can get all the fittings to turn out of their threads and reassemble the whole thing, I'd save it and do the work. A replacement one from Groco will be about $250.

But if anything's frozen-- especially if you are not the first guy to find that it is-- I'd be wary. Frozen fittings invariably tell tales of other attempts to bang them loose. You don't know what's gone on there-- if they're frozen, there's a reason, and it tends to lead one down the path of discovery to corrosion, brittleness, and metal fatigue. The intake strainer is one of the most vital parts of the boat, not just for what it does but for how vulnerable a point it is if it's compromised. Use heat (not too much), gentle persuasion, and patience. When reassembling, bronze-wool all the threads, polish towards golden prettiness, and use plenty of anti-seize.

BTW-- if you need to replace it, check out Great Lakes Skipper online. They liquidate discontinued boatbuilders' inventory and have quality new parts for pennies on the dollar. They'd have one of these.