Mac
Mary,I live in the desert and for now am forced to sail on lakes. It is a few hundred miles to anywhere I want to be on the water. Once I get there it is only practical to spend a few days and I prefer to be comfortable. Sometimes the wind blows, sometimes it doesn't. Interestingly enough, I always have to tinker with things. I love sailing but some of my friends also enjoy more motorized activities. Having said those things: The Mac is light and easily trailerable. The water ballast and swing board allow for shallow anchorages (NM lakes) and make loading and unloading easy. The boat is roomy and allows for multiple days "camping" aboard in comfort. With the larger engine I can pull water toys, get from point a to b quickly and get to shelter when one of our quick moving thunderstorms springs up. I also get to indulge my penchant for sailing. Some will tell you the Mac is slow--I guess in some regards it is but you can still develop your sailing skills and perhaps you become a better sailer eeking out that last bit. The Mac is considered quite spartan. While I enjoy the clean lines and lack of clutter, some miss the wood trim, etc. Because I enjoy tinkering the Mac is a blank canvas. My lines are lead aft, roller furling, inboard 18 gallon fuel tank, pressure water, 12 volt refrigeration, swampcooler, am/fm/cd changer, GPS, etc. I enjoy modifying the boat. The aquisition cost allows me the free resources to make some additions to the boat. Some will complain of the lightly built hull and rigging, yet I've never seen any confirmation of a Mac breaking apart or failing. It is not a blue water boat and was never intended to take horrendous punishment--it will however keep you safe with a bit of prudence. All in all it is a compromise that suits my needs for now. Of course I look at Hunters and admire the lines and quality, Catalinas, Lagunas, etc. There are some wonderful options and I realize that each of us make the choices we make based upon circumstance. Once you define your goals and expectations do some research and then sail some different boats. Your decision will become clearer then. P.S. Someday I will move to the water and probably choose a Gemini 105--a very different boat than the mac but I think I will always fondly remember this time...