Wheelpilot motor badly affecting compass - help

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nov 3, 2012
1
Catalina 320 Mk1 Mylor
My first post, so Hi all Catalina owners! :)

So - someone must have had this problem before and solved it - I hope!

Our 320 mk1 #303 was originally fitted with a binnacle compass and a Raymarine ST4000 wheel pilot - *no problems

Last year we replaced the pilot with a new Raymarine SPX-5. The design is similar to the ST4000 with a ring and drive motor that attaches to the wheel. The motor is in exactly the same position as the old motor, in relation to the compass.

However it appears that the new motor contains much stronger permanent magnets and this is causing such a great deviation to the compass that it cannot be corrected by a professional compass adjuster.

Raymarine’s suggested solution is to rotate *the drive wheel and motor so that it sits ( as you stand looking forward) in the 5 o'clock position rather than its current 9 o'clock position, thus moving the motor well below the binnacle compass.

However whilst this would work fine for a boat which had it's engine control panel on the cockpit wall, with our Catalina, as you will obviously be aware, the engine control panel is mounted in a pod that sits beneath the wheel. And on the top right of this pod is the pull-stop control for the engine!

Thus the motor cannot be put in the position that Raymarine suggest!

Trying to roatet it the other way, very little benefit can be gained because the clutch engagement lever fould against the top left side of the engine pod when the motor is in about the 8 o'clock position

I assume that current models have the same basic design and thus if you have an SPX-5 wheel pilot then presumably you have had the same problem?

If so - *what do you do to get around it!

many thanks

Graeme Clark
England. Two years a Cat owner!
 
Sep 6, 2007
324
Catalina 320 Gulfport, Fl
Re: Wheelpilot motor badly affecting compass - help

Mine was already set up with the motor at the 5 oclock position and the clutch handle did run into the instrament pod. I cut the handle shorter. The handle still engaged the tit which stops it from moving as the motor runs and all is well.
 

jrowan

.
Mar 5, 2011
1,294
O'Day 35 Severn River, Mobjack Bay, Va.
If you can't change the autopilot or controls on the binnacle, then maybe the simpler fix is to install another compass at another location, away from metal & magnetic objects. Many tiller steered boats have their compasses mounted on the rear cabin trunk on either side of the companionway. While its slightly more trouble to read, at least you will know that the compass is actually accurate. Many binnacle compasses are not all that accurate because there is so much metal mounted around the binnacle, post, wiring running through the post, etc. I honestly use my Garmin GPS plotter so much for navigation these days, I honestly rarely look at the binnacle compass, unless its just a quick glance to verify general direction. When I'm sighting something on land for navigation I like to use a hand held sighting compass, or the one mounted in my binnoculars. My 2 c.
 
Aug 16, 2009
1,000
Hunter 1986 H31 California Yacht Marina, Chula Vista, CA
What about raising the compass. On the Hunter Merriman binnacle there is a plastic riser about 2 1/2 inches high in which the compass sits. You might be able to fabricate something similar for your compass
 
Status
Not open for further replies.