use the acetone when its cold outside... what happend is the glue started to dissolve but the acetone evaporated (flashed off) so fast that it left a smear as the glue set up again.... lacquer thinner will work in place of the acetone also, and you can get it in slow, medium, or fast flash. use the slow.....
goof off evaporates slower, but is also a bit slower to dissolve the glue.... just stand there and keep it wet with goof off for a few minutes to soften the glue, and then scrape it off with a plastic scraper..... BUT, check to make sure the plastic scraper you use is solvent resistant, or it will make a worse mess...
if you have a gentle, steady hand you can use a razor blade scraper... after removing the bulk of it by scraping, use the rag and more solvent to clean the residue off...