Water Cooled Refrigeration

Status
Not open for further replies.

Rick D

.
Jun 14, 2008
7,183
Hunter Legend 40.5 Shoreline Marina Long Beach CA
What is your take on water-cooled refrigeration units? At what point do they produce a positive result from an energy-consumption standpoint?
 
R

Richard Kollmann, Kollmann Marine Inc.

RE: Water Cooled Big Mistake

On pleasure boats when the refrigeration compressors are larger than 1/6 Hour power the process heat is almost always removed by seawater. Water cooling these small refrigeration systems with 12/24 volt BD compressors is a mistake for many reasons; pump failures, pump air locks, screen clogging, plus additional amperage is required over air cooled, and total destruction of a system can occur when the seawater enters the refrigerant circuit. With the older model, fixed speed compressors there can be an improvement in efficiency when sea water temperature runs between 55 to 70¢ª F. On systems using the new Danfoss variable speed compressors, the added current required to drive a pump offsets the efficiency gained by running the compressor at a slower speed in most small boxes or cooler climates. There is one serious problem with using water cooling with the small Danfoss BD compressors, many of the small seawater condensers have failed due to electrolysis corrosion and this allows seawater to mix with the refrigerant and destroy the complete system. I devoted one section in my 12 volt book to this subject. If you want more information on seawater effects on refrigeration and energy to power it see FAQ #33 on my web page.
 
D

Dennis Thomas

Look at Keel cooler by Frigoboat

I'm sure that Richard knows more about this than I, but this product doesn't use a pump to circulate the water. There isn't even a fan. Just the compressor. The refrigerant is sent through a block attached to the boat with a through-hull. Really saves energy if the water is cool enough. Here in a Texas lake it can get into the low 80's for a while at the peak of summer but it should work even then.
 
Jun 11, 2004
73
- - Ft. Lauderdale FL.
All the facts are not in, So we get Opinions

I have recommended almost every piece of boat refrigeration equipment at one time. In making a recommendation I try to consider maintenance and reliability of the equipment I recommend. Are my opinions always correct? No, because I use a conservative approach to technical matters. It I see that a unit will not last ten to twenty years I don’t like to recommend it. I have recommended keel coolers on small boats without alternators when 3 amps-hrs per day is important. Below the water condensers do work when they do away with fan cooled condensers. Keel coolers and thru hull can reduce the amp hours on small 12 volt refrigeration by 3 to 6 amp-hrs a day. In tropical climates or when the compressor is located in a warm location a fan is still needed for cooling. I do not recommend either keel or through condensers on boats that have onboard generators or that spend time connected to shore power, due to electrolysis problems. And there have been unrepairable failures of seawater entering the compressors
 
Status
Not open for further replies.