ultrasonic antifouling

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jan 12, 2011
2
Hunter 43 Adelaide SA
Has anyone tried ultrasonic antifouling in conjunction with normal antifouling?
Any results or opinions?
I am a bit concerned about any sound waves and the effect they may have
 

Ivan

.
May 17, 2004
234
Hunter 356 Solomons MD
There are two questions

I have not tried the ultrasonic antifouling systems, however I am familiar with the physics. The systems I have seen advertised would not give me any concern about health effects, as they are so low-powered that it is doubtful that there would be any.

A bigger question is the effectiveness. I presume that the physics of ultrasonic waves interfere with marine organisms' chemical process whereby they attach thin filamentary threads into the surface, and then build on those. Thus they might be fairly effective right over the transducers. However, because the systems only have two or at most 3-4 transducers glued to the inside of the hull, the strength of the ultrasound field on the outside of the hull must vary greatly with the distance from the nearest transducer.

In fact the sound field strength, and thus presumably its effectiveness, falls off as the square of the distance from a transducer, and so the transducers must either be greatly over-designed to have a larger coverage area, or the antifouling will not be effective except right over the few transducers. So I would expect that the system coverage will be spotty at best, though I have no direct experience in using them.

Therefore I would recommend asking the manufacturer of any systems that you may be considering to buy a few questions such as: How even is the coverage over a hull of your length? Does the ultrasound deter all growth, or does it work on some though not other organisms, and if so which ones? Does it prevent slime growth? How well? And the summary question: Show me data on effectiveness compared to copper paint, at various distances from a transducer in a typical application.

A legitimate manufacturer who makes an effective product will have these data, and will be eager to share it with you to make a sale. If he does not, go elsewhere or stick with antifouling paint.
 
Jan 12, 2011
2
Hunter 43 Adelaide SA
Thankyou Ivan for your thoughts - I will endeavour to get more info before committing
The system I was looking at has 6 transducers
I was concerned abt the effectiveness as distance from transducer increased and also the the issue of any consistent sound waves and any possible effect on my hull etc
 
Jan 12, 2011
930
Hunter 410 full time cruiser
I have seen this question in lots of forums. So far other than manufaturers, I have never read someone say they like it and that it worked and was worth the cost.

But I keep hoping it becomes a good idea.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.