Good value
I wouldn't get too hung up on buying an exact replacement. I bought a replacement tiller from Defender for my Oday 23, and I bought the model that was listed as the replacement for the Ranger 26 and 28. I just checked the pyachts website, and they list my tiller (H&L model 112F) as the replacement for the Oday 27. Fits great, looks beautiful and is far more ergonomic than the straight stick it replaced. I went with a highly curved model because I was tired of banging the tiller against my knees. I found that Defender's prices were the lowest by far. I paid $63 for my tiller, when West Marine had the same model for $129.99. Pyachts lists it for about $70. I would also check out the Chandlery on this site. I have bought stuff there, and I can't say enough good things about their customer service.