Starter Battery replacement

Feb 10, 2015
11
Beneteau 343 Vancouver
Hello, All

I have just discovered that the aging starter battery on my 2008 343 is a dual purpose deep cycle battery. Is this standard equipment, or something that a previous owner must have done? Is there a good reason to have a dual purpose battery as a starter battery, and if so, what is it? Or, should I replace it with a standard starter battery?

TIA.

Lee
 
May 7, 2012
1,571
Hunter e33 Maple Bay, BC
Hello, All

I have just discovered that the aging starter battery on my 2008 343 is a dual purpose deep cycle battery. Is this standard equipment, or something that a previous owner must have done? Is there a good reason to have a dual purpose battery as a starter battery, and if so, what is it? Or, should I replace it with a standard starter battery?

TIA.

Lee
Well Lee, those with a higher level of knowledge then I have not chimed in so I will pass on my thoughts. If you normally start your diesel with this battery, then you probably should have a starter battery. If you normally start your diesel with your house bank then you should have a true deep cycle and rename this single battery from starting.battery to a reserve battery. Dual purpose batteries seem to be poor performers as a starting battery (relatively big amps for short periods) or as a house battery (small amps for long periods). Tests have shown that starting a diesel does not over stress deep cycles in the relatively short time needed to start the engine. Here is a link that may explain it better:
https://www.westmarine.com/WestAdvisor/Selecting-a-Marine-Storage-Battery
 

Ward H

.
Nov 7, 2011
3,798
Catalina 30 Mk II Cedar Creek, Bayville NJ
@CrazyOldMan
Yes, Deep cycle batteries are preferred. No need for a starter battery or dual purpose battery.
The link @Hello Below posted describes the difference in the three types of batteries.

So why are deep cycle batteries preferred for starting by many?
While you can use a starter battery for starting the small diesels in our sailboats, using a starter battery for house loads and only charging it occasionally will shorten the life of the starter battery.
Using a deep cycle battery for starting gives us a good reserve battery so that battery can also be used for house loads without shortening it's life.

Here is an excerpt from a post by Maine Sail, a member of this forum who is a marine electrician.
"Batteries calendar age too and are murdered much more rapidly by heat than folks often assume. I've seen no real world evidence that a battery used as reserve only lives a measurably longer life than one used for starting only. When wired properly both last a good long while. I have many dedicated starting batteries (usually "deep cycle" on sailboats) that last 6-12 years or more where the house/cycling bank has been replaced one, two or three times. When cheap auto-type starting batteries are used for starting or reserve applications the average life I see is about 3-7 years regardless of starting or reserve use. Whether used as a dedicated starting or reserve battery really seems to make little difference in longevity though battery type does."

If you normally start your diesel with your house bank then you should have a true deep cycle and rename this single battery from starting.battery to a reserve battery.
This is becoming the preferred way to think of and use your two battery banks. If you draw down the house bank too low to start the diesel or it otherwise fails in some way, you just switch to the reserve and use that for house loads and starting until the house bank is back up to normal.

Hope that answers your question.