Sign in here at SBO.com

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dec 2, 2003
480
Catalina C-320 Washington, NC
I have no issue with signing in to post.

My devalued $.02 worth. I personally think we all should post using our real names. I don't usually get into this debate when it comes up because I don't like being forced to do so, I prefer to set an example voluntarily. I also refuse to go to sites that require me to register just to look, that requirement is not in the spirit of an open Internet. Signing posts is not a credibility issue as I see it. Even though I invariably post over my real name, scrupulously try to respond with known facts, actual experience or observation and try to qualify my remarks when expressing an opinion, I am capable of posting an incredibly idiotic comment, so no one should ever take my advice without question. Everyone ought to verify all advice before following it in every case anyway. I find checking an answer can be easier than finding it first, so these lists are beneficial even to the skeptical among us. I believe, as others have previously alluded to, that accountability is the more significant issue. I observed long ago that once I began displaying a vanity tag with my name on it on my automobile, I felt more compelled to drive with a bit more courtesy and refrain from single digit salutes when cut off. While I no longer display such a tag, the sense of accountability has become more ingrained and I try to reflect on that consideration before raising the digit when tempted. I think that such accountability often engenders more consistent displays of courtesy and respect in other venues as well. For many, protecting the reputation of a screen name produces a similar effect, but I suspect perhaps to a slightly lesser degree. As to the security issues, the younger generations seem to accept such openness as the norm and as a matter of course. Perhaps the better response for us cautious old fogeys is to adopt that openness, but help to find better and more reliable ways of "behavioral modification" for those would exploit and violate the trust inherent in that openness. Regards
 

Jim

.
May 21, 2007
775
Catalina 36 MK II NJ
There is NO WAY to Validate the profile

The e-mail could also be a spam account. Login are worth nothing!
 
Feb 12, 2007
259
Ericson 25 Oshkosh, WI
Ground Hog Day

Did this issue not just come up about three months ago. It might have been more geared towards using your "real" name versus a screen name, now it has morphed into registration, WTF. Do what you please, register or dont. Phil will have the control of how "HE" wants to run his forums. We are all grown ups here and have a mind of our own. If you are on SBO enough you can figure out good advice from not so good. The biggest difference on this forum is that you have "extreme" sailors down to the "novice" sailor. What might be good advice to some, but it is just not practical, financially or situationally proper for others. It seems that in the last few months there have been some bizarre threads going on. Remember Patrick with the Morgan 33? There were personal attacks on this poor guy. People claimed he was a fraudulent poster and were out right mean to him. I was surprised that he even comes back here after that, but he was a real person. That was a fun thread last winter to read and watch his progress. Now last week it seems like someone wants to ridicule Ross, for what, being helpful and witty and WILLING to help people. Or worse off, because he has his name and address on his signature, wow, get a hobby people! How many people have learned many things from Ross. I know I have picked up advice from his years of expierences. Ross is a wise grasshopper! There are people that get off on being a dickhead behind there computer and have NOTHING else better to do with there time. I dont think registering will stop this, but it might make it more of a pain in the ass to do. It is summer time get out on your boats and take what you have learned from this site and apply it to what ever youre going to do. Report back on how it went and help someone that might be planning your last project or adventure.
 

Timo42

.
Mar 26, 2007
1,042
Venture 22 Marina del Rey
There are 2 issues here

One is trolls and members who go temporarily off their nut, the other is the profile. Phil seems to have a handle on the former issue, and the profile issue would imho be better addressed through gentle reminders during the course of discussions, where the advantage would be evident. Badges, we don't need no steenking badges ;D, but a burgee now, that would be something. *pop Tim
 
Jun 3, 2004
309
Prindle 18, beach catamaran Chicago (North Edgebrook), IL
Here's to Phil!

Thanks to Phil we have this great thing to get all defensive over. I think he is excercising proper restraint and the correct judgement in nearly all things. Each of us are personnaly responsible for sorting the wheat from the chaf, don't expect someone to do it for you.
 
Feb 17, 2006
5,274
Lancer 27PS MCB Camp Pendleton KF6BL
Remove the registration process...

...add a spell checker! :)
 
J

Jim

Rob, maybe you could tone done the

langauge a bit. There may be children reading this forum.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.