Very different cruising
Hi Cliff -Having sailed in all the areas you've mentioned, you should consider how adventurous you want to be vs. how relaxing a vacation you want. In general, I feel the cruising in the Gulf Island and the San Juans is similar, although there are typically more crowds south of the border. There are a myriad of places to choose from in either archipeligo, from quiet anchorages to resorts and bustling towns. Heading out the Strait of Juan de Fuca to Barkley can be a significant task, depending on the weather. It's a long run from Victoria or Sooke to Bamfield, but it can be done in one long day if conditions are favorable. Stopping in Port San Juan (Port Renfrew) is the only shelter available enroute, but it can be a somewhat uncomfortable anchorage with swells entering the bay - I try to avoid making a stop. The other consideration is August is often referred to as "Foggust" on the west coast of Vancouver Island, so I'd recommend having radar if you plan on being out there during this time. That being said, I've cruised Barkley and Clayoquot Sounds a 1/2 dozen times and prefer the west coast to the inside passage. You won't find nearly as many Bayliners out there and it's absolutely beautiful and wild. Really a worthwhile trip if you have the time and inclination, but this route does require more vigilant weather planning. In any case, I'm sure you'll have a great time!Trevor