My vote goes to Garhauer
There's other quality products out there but my dollars go to this family owned and run business that is really responsive when you have a question. Oh yeah, they showed up at the St. Pete boat show when many others bailed.
As kiprichard says, all your problems with the lift go away when you remove it. Mine came off 9 years ago and I've never missed the banging, clanging, tangling, chafing, etc.