Researching mystery San Diego Family of 4 whose Sea Dreamer sailboat disappeared south of Hawaii in 1989

Dec 28, 2019
6
Catalina 39 San Diego
I'm trying to learn about a missing family of 4 that disappeared south of Hawaii in August of 1989. The internet only has one article about the family--that of the sea search. That one is from the LA Times. Through a membership to newspapers dott comm, I was able to find 2 additional articles from the Honolulu Star Advertiser regarding the sea search, plus have the letter from the Air National Guard from last April. I'm attaching them for your perusal. Please note I have moved up substantially in their queue in the last 9 months.


Here is the only article online about this missing San Diego Family of 4:


San Diego


This is a volunteer effort on my part. No one is paying me, nor is there a financial gain in my learning about the missing family. My effort is similar to the motion of walking out of a public building and holding the door for someone entering….WHY do you do that, as there is nothing to gain? You hold the door as it is the considerate thing to do. Plus it feels good to help others.


Besides the occasional posting on a forum here, there seems like there’d be a lot of interest in learning about the Graham Hughes Family of 4 and their Sea Dreamer 39 foot sloop sailboat. I’m reminded of the 1983 “Red Sky in Mourning” book by Tami Oldham Ashcraft, which was made into the 2018 Film, “Adrift.” In that incident, one person died yet there’s lots known about the survivor. There is also the August of 1987 incident in which Garden Grove, CA attorney Manning John Eldridge’s sailboat “Marara” was found floating 1,500 miles south of Hawaii, sails shredded and partially demasted, with his skeletal remains onboard. In the present incident, a family of 4 perished yet NOTHING is known about who they were, their home port, the kind of sailboat, their skill as sailors or how much they prepared for their 1989 sailing.

Here's what I have learned in the last year:

• Obviously how this family of 4 died will never be known. It will never be known whether it was a rogue wave, a larger ship that ran them down or whether their sailboat hit sunken debris. The real story is whom they were and why nothing is known about them.

• There were no Missing Persons filed by family members in San Diego 4 county area in 1989;

• There are no birth certificates for son—Alex, 21 or Son—Ryan, 15 in San Diego County for their likely birth dates in the 1960s or 1970s;

• There are no death certificates filed for the family in California;

• There are no boat registrations on file for the Sea Dreamer with San Diego Marine/Aviation Unit as their records only go back to 2000. Similarly, the California boat registrar Dona Jenkins had no records of the Sea Dreamer, ever.

• Coast Guard, Air Force & Navy do not have any records for the 1989 sea search. Which is striking given the stated 300,000 square mile grid search area---a huge and likely expensive search;

• It is unclear if this Hughes family was related in any fashion to Howard Hughes. They share the same last name and location of San Diego. It is estimated a 39 foot sea sloop capable of bluewater sailing in the late 80s would have cost north of $100,000. This is seemingly out of reach for a young family. However, not out of reach of a young family related to Hughes Aircraft.

• My FOIA (Freedom of Information Act) requests of the U.S. Military branches involved in the search have only revealed one document related to the family. I’m told it is 20 pages long and in the possession of the Air National Guard. Currently, I’m holding at Position #144 with an expected fulfillment date by February of 2022.

• I was unable to find any sailboat registration for the Sea Dreamer in California owned by Graham or Sheri Hughes (or anyone with that last name) with the US Coast Guard. I also looked on BoatinfoWorld dott comm. There have been quite a few sailboats with that name registered and expired, but none that fit the specs currently known—39 foot sloop, made prior to 1989 with an earlier registration that is now expired. There are also no records for Hewes, Hughe or other possible misspellings of the family’s name.

• There are no Real Property records from Graham or Sheri Hughes in Imperial, Orange, Riverside or San Diego Counties in the 1970s or 1980s. It is like the family never existed.

• The lack of records in the family’s name, plus the “British-ness” of their name itself suggests to me that the Graham Hughes family may have been from Canada or the United Kingdom.

• I found records on Ancestry dott comm of a marriage between a “Graham D. Hughes” and a “Sheree Wheawall” in 1987 in Newcastle, Staffordshire, England. The only problem is that Graham was born in 1961 and Sheree in 1963. That would have made them 28 and 26, respectively, in 1989. This is far too young to have had a 21 year old son (Alex) and 15 year old son (Ryan).

• There are no pictures of the Sea Dreamer sailboat nor of the Graham Hughes family available online, nor any information of interviews of fellow sailors that knew the family and their sailing exploits and experience. Given the information age we are in, this mystery and the lack of information on the San Diego sailing family is very unusual.


I’m spending my own money on this matter. If you have any suggestions for me, or know how I can conclusively trace the Sea Dreamer sailboat registration in California or any other states, you can reach me in Orlando, Florida at four oh seven, seven one nine, six nine eight eight. Call or Text. You can also email me at stormstoppers dott john at gmail dott com. Thank you!
 

Attachments

Apr 8, 2010
2,087
Ericson Yachts Olson 34 28400 Portland OR
I hope you find enough information, eventually, to write a book about it. That is indeed *quite* a mystery.
 

dLj

.
Mar 23, 2017
4,217
Belliure 41 Back in the Chesapeake
There is a fundamental assumption that is incorrect. You have assumed the boat went missing. The boat may have simply changed from Hawaii as end port to San Diego as end port. That, in fact, is the more logical conclusion from the I formation you have.

dj
 
Dec 28, 2019
6
Catalina 39 San Diego
There is a fundamental assumption that is incorrect. You have assumed the boat went missing. The boat may have simply changed from Hawaii as end port to San Diego as end port. That, in fact, is the more logical conclusion from the I formation you have.

dj
Your assumption was refuted by the USCG in 1989. Read the 2 Star Advertiser articles attached to the post. One says the USCG “did an extensive search off the coast of California on the assumption the sailboat returned to the home port of San Diego but turned up nothing.” If your assertion was true, the family would have been located but they were not and remain missing.
 
Feb 20, 2011
8,048
Island Packet 35 Tucson, AZ/San Carlos, MX
There is a fundamental assumption that is incorrect. You have assumed the boat went missing. The boat may have simply changed from Hawaii as end port to San Diego as end port. That, in fact, is the more logical conclusion from the I formation you have.

dj
That possibility is mentioned in the last .pdf posted.
Good luck, @stormstoppers
 

capta

.
Jun 4, 2009
4,905
Pearson 530 Admiralty Bay, Bequia SVG
I'm not sure when satellite weather became available to all, but when I made the crossing between Hawaii and Tahiti in '72 we encountered a severe storm which we, many years later, came to realize was a hurricane that came off the Central American coast. Back in those days nobody had any inkling that these storms were as common and far reaching as we now know they are.
I would attribute the disappearance of any small craft in that area, before satellite weather, to one of these storms, not a larger ship running them down, floating debris, or a rogue wave as you suggest.
 
  • Like
Likes: jssailem

jssailem

SBO Weather and Forecasting Forum Jim & John
Oct 22, 2014
22,752
CAL 35 Cruiser #21 moored EVERETT WA
Perhaps she was one of these?

OFFICIAL NUMBER: 663360
HULL NUMBER: SERF39430783
IMO NUMBER:
VESSEL NAME:
SEA DREAMER
HAILING PORT: LITTLE ROCK AR
YEAR BUILT: 1983
LENGTH - FEET: 39
BREADTH - FEET: 13.9
DEPTH - FEET: 7
GROSS TONS: 25
NET TONS: 20
SELF PROPELLED: Yes
PROPULSION TYPE: UNSPECIFIED
HULL MATERIAL: FRP (Fiberglass)
HULL CONFIGURATION: Monohull
HULL SHAPE: Ship
SERVICE TYPE: Recreational
CERTIFICATE ISSUED: 12/12/2017
CERTIFICATE EXPIRES: 1/31/2019
CERTIFICATE STATUS: Case Pending
ENDORSEMENTS: Recreation
BUILDER: SEA RAY BOATS INC
HULL BUILT: MERRITT ISLAND, FL, UNITED STATES
VESSEL COMPLETED:
OFFICIAL NUMBER: 1040378
HULL NUMBER: EYS371730478
IMO NUMBER:
VESSEL NAME:
SEA DREAMER
HAILING PORT: TACOMA WA
YEAR BUILT:
LENGTH - FEET:
37.8
BREADTH - FEET: 13.5
DEPTH - FEET: 5.8
GROSS TONS: 19
NET TONS: 15
SELF PROPELLED: Yes
PROPULSION TYPE: UNSPECIFIED
HULL MATERIAL: FRP (Fiberglass)
HULL CONFIGURATION: Monohull
HULL SHAPE: Ship
SERVICE TYPE: Recreational
CERTIFICATE ISSUED: 7/18/2018
CERTIFICATE EXPIRES: 7/31/2019
CERTIFICATE STATUS: Valid
ENDORSEMENTS: Recreation
BUILDER:
HULL BUILT:
VESSEL COMPLETED:
OFFICIAL NUMBER: 1079773
HULL NUMBER: RGMKC115K697
IMO NUMBER:
VESSEL NAME:
SEA DREAMER
HAILING PORT: TRAVERSE CITY MI
YEAR BUILT:
LENGTH - FEET:
39.4
BREADTH - FEET: 13.1
DEPTH - FEET: 6.1
GROSS TONS: 21
NET TONS: 16
SELF PROPELLED: Yes
PROPULSION TYPE: UNSPECIFIED
HULL MATERIAL: FRP (Fiberglass)
HULL CONFIGURATION: Monohull
HULL SHAPE: Ship
SERVICE TYPE: Recreational
CERTIFICATE ISSUED: 8/7/2007
CERTIFICATE EXPIRES: 9/30/2008
CERTIFICATE STATUS: Expired
ENDORSEMENTS: Recreation
BUILDER: UNKNOWN
HULL BUILT: UNKNOWN
VESSEL COMPLETED:
 
Dec 28, 2019
6
Catalina 39 San Diego
Perhaps she was one of these?

OFFICIAL NUMBER: 663360
HULL NUMBER: SERF39430783
IMO NUMBER:
VESSEL NAME:
SEA DREAMER
HAILING PORT: LITTLE ROCK AR
YEAR BUILT: 1983
LENGTH - FEET: 39
BREADTH - FEET: 13.9
DEPTH - FEET: 7
GROSS TONS: 25
NET TONS: 20
SELF PROPELLED: Yes
PROPULSION TYPE: UNSPECIFIED
HULL MATERIAL: FRP (Fiberglass)
HULL CONFIGURATION: Monohull
HULL SHAPE: Ship
SERVICE TYPE: Recreational
CERTIFICATE ISSUED: 12/12/2017
CERTIFICATE EXPIRES: 1/31/2019
CERTIFICATE STATUS: Case Pending
ENDORSEMENTS: Recreation
BUILDER: SEA RAY BOATS INC
HULL BUILT: MERRITT ISLAND, FL, UNITED STATES
VESSEL COMPLETED:

OFFICIAL NUMBER: 1040378
HULL NUMBER: EYS371730478
IMO NUMBER:
VESSEL NAME:
SEA DREAMER
HAILING PORT: TACOMA WA
YEAR BUILT:
LENGTH - FEET:
37.8
BREADTH - FEET: 13.5
DEPTH - FEET: 5.8
GROSS TONS: 19
NET TONS: 15
SELF PROPELLED: Yes
PROPULSION TYPE: UNSPECIFIED
HULL MATERIAL: FRP (Fiberglass)
HULL CONFIGURATION: Monohull
HULL SHAPE: Ship
SERVICE TYPE: Recreational
CERTIFICATE ISSUED: 7/18/2018
CERTIFICATE EXPIRES: 7/31/2019
CERTIFICATE STATUS: Valid
ENDORSEMENTS: Recreation
BUILDER:
HULL BUILT:
VESSEL COMPLETED:

OFFICIAL NUMBER: 1079773
HULL NUMBER: RGMKC115K697
IMO NUMBER:
VESSEL NAME:
SEA DREAMER
HAILING PORT: TRAVERSE CITY MI
YEAR BUILT:
LENGTH - FEET:
39.4
BREADTH - FEET: 13.1
DEPTH - FEET: 6.1
GROSS TONS: 21
NET TONS: 16
SELF PROPELLED: Yes
PROPULSION TYPE: UNSPECIFIED
HULL MATERIAL: FRP (Fiberglass)
HULL CONFIGURATION: Monohull
HULL SHAPE: Ship
SERVICE TYPE: Recreational
CERTIFICATE ISSUED: 8/7/2007
CERTIFICATE EXPIRES: 9/30/2008
CERTIFICATE STATUS: Expired
ENDORSEMENTS: Recreation
BUILDER: UNKNOWN
HULL BUILT: UNKNOWN
VESSEL COMPLETED:
Not possible for a sailboat that disappeared in 1989. All 3 hailing ports are wrong, all 3 are shown as “ships” not sails and all 3 have paperwork issued over 20 years after the sea dreamer vanished. Find a Sea Dreamer owned by someone named Hughes and it will be new information!
 
Dec 28, 2019
6
Catalina 39 San Diego
In response to “just some guy”: Your assumption was refuted by the USCG in 1989. Read the 2 Star Advertiser articles attached to the post. One says the USCG “did an extensive search off the coast of California on the assumption the sailboat returned to the home port of San Diego but turned up nothing.” If your assertion was true, the family would have been located but they were not and remain missing.


In response to jssaillem: Not possible for a sailboat that disappeared in 1989. All 3 hailing ports are wrong, all 3 are shown as “ships” not sails and 2 of the 3 have paperwork issued over 20 years after the sea dreamer vanished. Find a Sea Dreamer owned by someone named Hughes in the 70s or 80s and it will be new information!
 
May 24, 2004
7,164
CC 30 South Florida
They may or may not ever had existed. From your research the only assertion that they existed was an Article from the LA Times; try to contact the Reporter or the Editor and find out how they got the story. Here in Florida the USCG gets fake calls about distressed vessels at sea all the time, those that seem credible are searched and investigated. Many times are diversionary tactics used by smugglers to move USCG resources away from their area.
 
Feb 17, 2006
5,274
Lancer 27PS MCB Camp Pendleton KF6BL
OK, I have to ask the purpose of this thread? Why are you interested in something that "may" or "may not" have happened 30 years ago? And why HERE of all places? I really doubt anyone here ever hear of this vessel or seen the LAT article, let alone remember it.

So, do us a favor and tell us what you want us to do? I also have a vested interested in this, but not for the same reasons the OP has.
 
Dec 28, 2019
6
Catalina 39 San Diego
brian: did you read my original post with all my investigative dead ends? I posted looking for fresh ideas. Have any? My contact info is at bottom. Please read three attachments including affidavit from Air National Guard. Mahalo!
 
Feb 17, 2006
5,274
Lancer 27PS MCB Camp Pendleton KF6BL
No, not for something that is 30 years old. Someone mention contacting the LA Times. I recommend the same course of action.
 
Oct 2, 2008
3,810
Pearson/ 530 Strafford, NH
I agree with Brian, pre-internet news was always in the papers. Most little publishers are now gone or swallowed up by the survivors and most of the information has disappeared. I once did a search for a local paper I had read weekly in the 80’s and couldn’t find any references. Good luck with your search.
 
Nov 26, 2012
1,654
C&C 40-2 Berkeley
Seems that the most likely explanation is that this never happened at all. Explains everything.
 
Nov 26, 2012
1,654
C&C 40-2 Berkeley
We know the names and ages but we have no record that they existed? That does not makes sense. We know they left Tahiti and were bound for Hawaii? Where did this info come from? The paper reports a coast guard search and even lists the officer’s name but there is no record with the coast guard? Hmmmm. Sounds made up.
 
Dec 28, 2019
6
Catalina 39 San Diego
We know the names and ages but we have no record that they existed? That does not makes sense. We know they left Tahiti and were bound for Hawaii? Where did this info come from? The paper reports a coast guard search and even lists the officer’s name but there is no record with the coast guard? Hmmmm. Sounds made up.
Hmm....or perhaps 30 years ago there were records and they weren’t kept over time. I have to say I’m kind of disappointed at your reading comprehension skills. Tahiti? Where did you read that? In case you are wondering, I spoke with both USCG quartermasters and they remember the extensive sea search in 1989. So clearly it’s not made up.

I had no idea this forum had so many dumb participants. Were you and Brian extras in The Ringer with Johnny Knoxville? That fits.
 
Feb 20, 2011
8,048
Island Packet 35 Tucson, AZ/San Carlos, MX
I had no idea this forum had so many dumb participants.
I'd think it to be proportional to the general populace, if not slightly less.

Welcome to the internet, and goodbye!
 
Last edited: