I once had both the eyebrows and the handrails of PlasTeak. At the time they only made the one color and it was too light for my taste. The handrails are back to the original teak. I did one side with striping tape, did a lousy job and never did the other side. Now I have some nice pieces cut but not drilled nor varnished in the basement, some kind of cedar. But "Missings" tale makes me think I should try the PlasTeak in the darker color. I still have one traveler base as PlasTeak and plan to do the other. I would also like to do the winch pads but getting the winches and heavy cleats off is a problem. Was it Rardi who painted his cockpit teak? I guess you could just paint the eyebrows. He recommended the Hammered version of Rustoleum for that.
In the picture you can see the dorade lid, traveler base, and a little of the handrail and eyebrow in the light PlasTeak.