Its been done before
Go to the boat information section of this site then on to the Hunter 25.5 boat information page. You'll find a link to a 25.5 bottom job that documents the job. The author removes all the old paint, applies VC-tar and then VC-17.http://www.sailboatowners.com/upload/display.tpl?folder=73146032935&fno=17I'm not sure that this combination is only for racers. My 25.5 had the same combo when I bought her.IIRC, VC-17 requires VC-tar. I applied Micron CSC over the VC-tar after I lightly saneded all the remaining VC-17 off. I wanted multi-season, multi-haul capability. I'm not sure VC-17 provides that.Another consideration for VC-17 is that you can't scrub the slime off of the bottom without removing the paint.Also, since you're in Chicago and sailing fresh water, consider a paint with anti-slime capabilities even if its the version of VC-17 with Biolux. Otherwise, you will need to haul, clean the slime, then re-apply move VC-17 (after some surface prep).