a couple of things.... when I have not been able to find a new gasket, but the old one is still kinda usable (like the one you show), I have coated it thinly with 4200 or 5200 and let it cure out.... then put the part back into service as normal. it holds the old crispy gasket together and creates a good seal again.
the 5200 needs to be worked in good to fill as many of the little check marks in the old gasket as possible.
I have used silicone also, but the 3M product seems to be better.
but if you are intent on finding new ones, and yet find the parts are no longer available, you can take one of your old ones (or the hatch lens) to a gasket supply or gasket specialties place in your area and have some custom cut to your pattern, out of any type of material and thickness you want.