Galiostro, You are identifying the right areas to check. Prop, Tach, prop pitch, bottom. This assumes under power.
How is the boat sailing?
A 3 blade will provide improved thrust under power, while a 2 bladed prop will reduce drag while sailing. This improved thrust comes at compromise, sailing speed. You may have more power in the engine but the prop pitch is too high. So your prop digs into the water while pulling the stern down causing more drag slower speed. You need to consider all of the elements in putting the best prop system in the water.
Finally, no info on how the boat is loaded.
Your old boat. Did you have as much water, fuel and gear on the old boat as you have on the new boat?
If you are loaded to go on a 3 month cruise you will be slower and deeper in the water than if you are prepared to go for a day sail race with nothing in the boat except the crew and minimal weight.